The Neighbor Who Knew Everythingby Mara Smith
×
Free PreviewRead the first 10% — no account required.
The Neighbor Who Knew Everything cover
Preview

CHAPTER ONE The Woman Next Door

The first thing the woman next door said to Claire Bennett was that she should stop apologizing for the broken glass.

Claire hadn’t told anyone on the street about the glass.

She stood on the front step holding a cardboard carton against her hip. Inside were three chipped cereal bowls, a dead flashlight, and a framed photograph with a crack running through the face of the woman pictured there. She had meant to put everything in the garage. Instead she watched a moving truck inch backward into the driveway next door while a man in a fluorescent vest shouted instructions no one appeared to be following.

The woman emerged from behind the truck carrying two paper coffee cups. She was slim and neat in cream trousers and a pale blue blouse, dressed as though she had arrived for lunch rather than to supervise the transfer of an entire household. A dark bob swung against her jaw when she turned her head. She came up Claire’s walk with an ease that suggested the walk already belonged to her.

“I’m sorry,” Claire said, moving the carton out of the way.

The woman smiled. “See? You did it again.”

“Again?”

“You don’t have to apologize. Especially not over a broken glass.”

Claire looked at the coffee cups. Behind her, the front door stood open to the dim hallway. Yesterday evening she had swept a shattered drinking glass out of the kitchen and carried the pieces to the trash beneath old grocery receipts. She had done it after Daniel went upstairs. The glass itself had been ordinary, part of a set they had owned for eight years. The argument surrounding it had not.

“Sorry,” Claire said, then heard herself and stopped.

“That makes three.” The woman offered a cup. “Evelyn Shaw. Your new neighbor.”

“Claire Bennett.”

“I know.”

The answer came so readily that Claire felt a small tightening below her ribs. Evelyn tipped her chin toward the curb.

“It’s on the mailbox. I promise I haven’t been studying you.”

BENNETT was painted in white block letters on black metal. One of the T’s had begun to peel, its upright leg curling away from the surface. Claire had been meaning to replace the letters since spring.

“Right,” she said. “Of course.”

Evelyn’s expression softened. “I hope I haven’t startled you. I had two coffees delivered and realized I’d ordered one more than I could drink.”

A little unlikely, perhaps, but the cup was warm and Claire’s hands were cold. November had arrived without warning. Overnight, the air had turned brittle. Leaves skittered across the drive and collected beneath the wheels of the moving van.

“What is it?” Claire asked.

“Oat-milk latte. Two shots. A touch of vanilla.”

It was exactly what Claire ordered at the café near the library.

“That’s strange,” she said.

“What is?”

“It’s what I drink.”

Evelyn laughed. “Then I’ve already done one thing right.”

Claire accepted the cup. The lid had a faint dent where a thumb must have pressed it down. She could have asked why the second drink happened to be hers, but she was aware of the movers watching the narrow space between their trucks, of the carton digging into her forearm, of Evelyn standing in her yard waiting to be welcomed.

“Thank you,” Claire said. “That’s kind.”

“It’s nothing.” Evelyn glanced past her through the open door. “You have a lovely home.”

“It’s a work in progress.”

“Aren’t they all? I love the blue in your kitchen. It’s so cheerful.”

Claire turned slightly. From the front step she could see only the hallway, painted the pale gray Daniel had chosen, and a sliver of the living-room doorway. The kitchen was at the rear of the house, beyond a short passage that bent left. Its cabinets, which Claire had painted herself three summers earlier, were a deep, muted blue.

“You’ve seen the kitchen?”

Evelyn took a small sip. “I was admiring the photographs in the listing when I looked at houses on this street. Maybe I’m remembering that. Or I’m confusing yours with another.”

Claire considered this. Their house had not been on the market since before they bought it, but old real-estate photographs remained online for years. She had found pictures of their bathroom once, with its previous owner’s pink towels still hanging beside the sink.

“Probably the listing,” she said.

“Probably.”

A mover called Evelyn’s name. She raised one finger to indicate he should wait.

“I met your husband earlier,” Evelyn said. “Daniel? He was leaving for work.”

Claire was surprised by how quickly the remark eased her. There was the answer to the coffee, perhaps even the glass. Daniel had been out by his car at seven, checking messages before the drive downtown. He could have spoken to Evelyn then.

“He didn’t mention that.”

“It was hardly a conversation. I introduced myself. He seemed in a hurry.”

“He usually is.”

Evelyn’s smile changed. Not much. Just enough to suggest that the sentence contained more information than Claire had intended to give.

“Then I won’t keep you,” Evelyn said. “But come over for a proper coffee once the boxes are out of the way. No obligation. I know what first weeks in a new place are like.”

She turned toward the moving truck, then looked back. “And if you ever need anything, Claire, knock. I’m right there.”

Claire watched her go. The coffee smelled sweet beneath the cardboard lid. She took a sip before she realized she was still holding the carton against her hip.

Inside, her phone was ringing.

By the time she reached the kitchen, the caller had hung up. Daniel’s name filled the screen over a photograph taken on the beach seven years ago. In it, his arm was around her shoulders and both of them were squinting into the sun. Claire had always liked the picture because it made them look like people who didn’t know how unhappy they could become.

She set the coffee beside the sink and called him back.

“Everything all right?” Daniel asked.

“Yes. You called me.”

“I know. I was checking whether you found the insurance folder.”

Claire looked toward the drawer beneath the kitchen phone charger. She had searched that drawer twice the previous night and once that morning. Daniel insisted the folder was there, although he was the last person to have used it.

“Not yet.”

A breath through his nose. It was a sound he made often now, not quite a sigh, though it performed the same work.

“Claire.”

“I looked.”

“I’m sure you did. Did you look under the warranty papers?”

“Yes.”

“Because yesterday you told me you couldn’t find the passport, and it was in the desk drawer where we keep the passports.”

“That drawer was locked.”

“That’s because I locked it. We keep important things there.”

She put her free hand on the edge of the sink. Across the room, light from the backyard window struck the blue cabinets and revealed a patch of brushwork she had never finished sanding smooth.

“I know where we keep important things.”

“I’m not saying you don’t.” His voice grew patient in a way that made her feel childish for having raised hers at all. “I just need the policy number before noon. If you can’t find it, tell me and I’ll handle it tonight.”

“I’ll look again.”

“Good.” There was a pause. “Anything else?”

“The new neighbor moved in.”

“Did she?”

“You met her.”

“Oh. Right. Evelyn. Nice woman.”

Claire lifted the coffee cup, considering how to phrase the question without sounding as though she were checking up on him.

“Did you tell her how I take my coffee?”

“What?”

“She brought me one. It was exactly right.”

“Then you’ve made a friend. That might be good for you.”

“Daniel.”

“No, I didn’t give a stranger your coffee order. I said hello when she pulled up. Was there something you wanted?”

“Nothing.”

“Okay. I have to go.” His voice shifted, brightening in the direction of somebody else. “I’ll call you later.”

The line ended. Claire remained by the sink, her thumb resting against the warm paper cup. She heard a closet door slide across its track upstairs, then realized it was only the mover’s metal ramp scraping against the truck bed next door.

She opened the drawer below the charger. At the very back, underneath a pile of appliance manuals, lay the insurance folder. She stared at it without touching it. The bright red tab was visible where she was certain it had not been visible before.

She could almost hear Daniel saying he had told her so.

She took the folder out and photographed the policy page. Then she sent him the number, adding, Found it. You were right.

Three dots appeared. Disappeared. Appeared again.

Thanks, sweetheart, he wrote.

By ten, the truck had unloaded a sofa, six dining chairs, and a tall mirror wrapped in gray blankets. Claire could tell the difference between the sound of a dresser being lowered and the sound of one being dropped. The house next door had stood empty for nearly eleven months, and its sudden return to life seemed to disturb the quiet she’d grown accustomed to.

She made a list on the back of an envelope: groceries, dry cleaning, hardware store, call insurance company. Beside the last item she put a question mark. Daniel had not explained why he needed the policy number so urgently. He rarely explained a task once he had decided it was practical. She used to find that efficient. Lately it felt as though every small job came with a test she hadn’t known she was taking.

At eleven, someone knocked.

Evelyn stood on the front porch without her coat. Behind her, the air was bright and cold enough to color the tips of her ears.

“I’m going to owe you an apology,” Evelyn said.

Claire almost smiled. “Apparently that’s my department.”

“I have a question, not a crisis. Do you know where the outdoor shutoff valve is? The kitchen tap next door keeps coughing air.”

“The water was off while the house was vacant. It might need a few minutes.”

“The men are convinced it’s broken.”

“Are they plumbers?”

“Not one of them, which hasn’t hurt their confidence.”

Claire laughed. It escaped before she could stop it, and for a moment Evelyn seemed relieved to hear it.

“The shutoff’s probably in the basement,” Claire said. “I can show you where ours is, if you want to know what to look for.”

“That’s generous.” Evelyn glanced at Claire’s slippers. “But you don’t have to go to any trouble. I can call someone.”

It was the sort of invitation that made refusal awkward: an offer to spare Claire work after Claire had already offered to help.

“It’s fine,” Claire said.

She stepped outside and pulled the door shut behind her. In the next yard, a wooden crate leaned against the garage wall, its shipping label printed in black type. Evelyn walked at Claire’s pace and said nothing until they reached the side gate.

“Daniel mentioned you redid the kitchen yourself,” Evelyn said.

Claire glanced at her. “He did?”

“Was I not supposed to know?”

“No. It’s just—he doesn’t usually talk about my projects.”

“He said you were patient.”

Claire thought of Daniel standing in the doorway while she painted, asking whether she was going to finish before his parents visited. He had not called her patient then.

“That’s nice of him,” she said.

Evelyn studied her face. Claire couldn’t tell whether the look was curiosity or sympathy.

They found the valve behind a utility panel near the basement stairs. Evelyn listened carefully, repeating Claire’s explanation and asking sensible questions. She didn’t need Claire to demonstrate anything. When they emerged, one of the movers said he’d already found the problem: a closed valve beside the water heater.

“See?” Evelyn said to him. “I told you the woman next door would know.”

The mover smiled at Claire. She felt absurdly pleased.

At the gate, Evelyn touched her arm once, lightly, before letting go. “Thank you. You’ve saved my morning.”

“Anyone would have helped.”

“Maybe. Not everyone would have made me feel welcome.”

Claire went home thinking about that sentence. Daniel said she was sensitive. Her mother said she had always worried too much about offending people. She could not remember the last time someone had described her as welcoming, or made it sound like a thing worth being.

At one thirty that Tuesday, she met Nora Price for an impromptu lunch at the café near the library. Nora was late, with a canvas bag over one shoulder and rainwater on the knees of her jeans. She apologized once, sincerely, and then forgot about it.

“You look tired,” Nora said after ordering soup.

“Thank you.”

“That’s not a compliment.”

“I know.”

“Are you sleeping?”

“Enough.”

Nora watched her for a moment. “That’s a word that can mean anything.”

Outside the window, school buses moved through traffic with their lights blinking. Claire traced the rim of her cup.

“We had an argument last night.”

“About what?”

Claire considered telling her about the glass. It had started because Daniel had asked why the bank statement was still on the counter. She had asked why several transfers she didn’t recognize were listed on it. He said she had agreed to move the money. She said she hadn’t. He reminded her of a conversation she couldn’t remember and then asked whether she was going to accuse him of lying every time she forgot something. When Daniel leaned across the counter for the statement, his elbow caught a glass and sent it onto the tile. He blamed her before she could speak.

By the time the shards stopped sliding, the argument had become about the broken glass.

“Money,” she said.

Nora waited.

“It’s complicated.”

“Is it complicated, or does Daniel say it’s complicated?”

Claire pressed her thumb against a chip in the cup’s glaze. “That’s not fair.”

“To who?”

Nora had known her since their first office job, long enough to ask questions nobody else asked. It made her both indispensable and, on days like this, difficult to be around.

“He handles the investments,” Claire said. “I don’t always keep up.”

“You don’t have to know every investment to ask where your savings went.”

“It’s not gone. He says he shifted it.”

“Then ask him to show you.”

“He will.”

Nora tilted her head. “Has he?”

Claire looked outside. One bus was stopped at the light, its driver leaning forward over the wheel. She did not answer.

Nora tore her bread in half and pushed the larger piece toward Claire. “You can come over tonight if you want company. You don’t need a reason.”

“I know.”

“I’m serious.”

“I know you’re serious.”

They spoke then about Nora’s unreliable furnace and a mutual friend’s new puppy. Claire was grateful for the change of subject. She was equally grateful that Nora hadn’t accepted the first explanation and let it rest.

The sky had gone gray by the time Claire returned home. A stack of flattened boxes stood beside Evelyn’s garage. Her front curtains were open, and light gleamed on the tall mirror, now leaning against the dining-room wall. Evelyn was inside with a man in a dark jacket. As Claire pulled into her driveway, the man turned his head toward the window. She saw only the pale oval of his face before he stepped out of view.

She carried her groceries in through the side door. Her phone buzzed with a message from Daniel.

Working late. Don’t wait on dinner.

She typed, Okay. Then, without knowing why, added, I found the insurance folder. She had already told him. She erased the second sentence and sent only the first.

A few minutes later the doorbell rang.

Evelyn held a covered dish in both hands. Her hair had loosened at the ends, and a dark mark crossed one sleeve of her blouse.

“Before you say no,” she began, “this is a peace offering for dragging you into my plumbing emergency. I ordered too much from the little Italian place on the corner. Apparently a portion for two means six.”

The dish smelled of roasted tomatoes and garlic. Claire had planned to eat toast.

“That’s really not necessary.”

“Neither was your help.” Evelyn extended it. “Please. I’ll feel less ridiculous.”

Claire took the dish. She was about to invite Evelyn in when she remembered the blue cabinets. Instead she stepped back into the hall and balanced the container against her stomach.

“Thank you,” she said. “This is lovely.”

“Eat while it’s hot.” Evelyn’s gaze moved beyond Claire’s shoulder, but she made no comment about what she saw. “And don’t stay up waiting for Daniel. People who work late have a way of forgetting that other people are waiting.”

Claire felt a rush of embarrassment. “He isn’t—”

“Of course not. I didn’t mean anything by it.”

Evelyn’s expression was open and apologetic. Claire wondered if she had imagined the edge in the remark.

“Good night,” she said.

“Good night, Claire.”

When the door closed, Claire stood motionless in the hall.

She hadn’t told Evelyn that Daniel was working late.

That was not, by itself, unusual. Evelyn might have seen his car leave in the morning and guessed he would return after dark. Or he might have mentioned his schedule while the moving truck arrived. People guessed accurately all the time. Claire was doing what Daniel complained she did: turning a harmless detail into something heavy.

Still, she opened her messages and checked the time. Daniel had written at 4:18. Evelyn’s doorbell visit had happened at 4:27.

Claire carried the dish into the kitchen. The light above the sink had begun to flicker again. Daniel said it needed a new bulb, though Claire had replaced it twice. She placed the dish on the counter, took out two plates, then put one away.

The broken glass from the previous night had left a small white mark in the grout. She crouched to inspect it. One tiny splinter remained lodged beside the cabinet toe-kick. She picked it out with the edge of an envelope and wrapped it in a paper towel.

As she straightened, a blue light blinked near the back door.

Their indoor security camera was mounted high in the corner, aimed at the mudroom entrance. Daniel had installed it after a package theft two winters earlier. He said it recorded only movement near the door and that no one could see the kitchen from its angle. Claire had taken his word for it. She had never liked the little machine, but she’d stopped noticing it.

Now she watched its indicator pulse, fade, and pulse again.

She crossed the room and stood beneath it. From here, the lens appeared to face farther into the kitchen than she remembered. Perhaps Daniel had adjusted it while cleaning. Perhaps the casing had settled on its mount. She could not tell.

Her phone rang. She startled, ashamed of how quickly her heart had begun to beat.

It was Daniel.

“Everything okay?” she asked.

“Of course. I just remembered we have that estimate coming tomorrow. Can you be there at nine?”

“What estimate?”

“The electrical work.”

Claire looked at the flickering light. “You said it was a bulb.”

“It’s probably the wiring. I told you the electrician might stop by.”

“You said someone might come next week.”

A pause. Then the patient voice again. “Claire, I can’t keep going over conversations we’ve already had.”

She closed her eyes. There was the phrase. The line he used when a disagreement was nearly finished, no matter who had been right at the beginning.

“All right,” she said. “I’ll be here.”

“Thanks. And Claire?”

“Yes?”

“Try not to worry about every little thing. It’ll wear you out.”

After he hung up, Claire moved the dinner dish to the dining-room table and ate standing up. Across the darkening yard, the lamp in Evelyn’s front room turned on. For an instant a silhouette crossed behind the curtain, too tall to be Evelyn’s. The man in the dark jacket, perhaps. A friend. A relative. A mover who hadn’t gone home yet.

Claire pulled the kitchen blind halfway down.

The camera’s small blue light blinked again.

She considered asking Daniel how to check its recordings. Instead she unlocked her phone and searched for the model number printed on the side. There were three results for how to change the camera’s viewing angle, two advertisements, and a help page about shared access.

She tapped the last one.

A heading appeared: WHO CAN VIEW YOUR CAMERA?

Beneath it were instructions for opening a list of authorized users. Claire read the first line, then looked toward the back door. She had never checked that list. Until tonight, she had not known it existed.

Next door, through the narrow gap beneath Evelyn’s curtain, a second lamp came on.

Claire reached up and turned the camera toward the wall.

CHAPTER TWO The Perfect Neighbor

The next morning, the camera was pointed at the door again.

Claire noticed it while the kettle warmed. She had left the lens facing the wall, turned until the black circle was almost hidden by its own plastic housing. Now its little glass eye looked out over the mudroom, the laundry basket, and the far end of the kitchen counter.

She stood beneath it in bare feet and felt the cold from the tile climb through her heels.

Daniel had come home after eleven. She had heard his key in the lock and the faint scrape of his briefcase against the hall table. She had been awake, although she had kept her eyes shut when he entered the bedroom. At some point during the night, he had been downstairs. That was all she knew. The camera had not moved itself, but she couldn’t say who had touched it.

“Your water’s boiling,” Daniel said behind her.

She turned. He had on a white shirt with the cuffs unbuttoned, his tie looped around his neck. He looked rested in the way he often did after evenings she remembered as difficult.

“I turned this toward the wall last night.”

“The camera?”

“Yes.”

He glanced up. “Why?”

“I was trying to see where it pointed.”

“You could just use the app.”

“I don’t have the app.”

Daniel opened a drawer, took out a spoon, and studied the clean utensils as if choosing among them required concentration. “I thought I put it on your phone.”

“You didn’t.”

“Then I’ll show you tonight.”

Claire waited for him to say he had moved the camera. Instead he stirred sugar into a cup of coffee he usually drank black.

“Was it you?” she asked.

“Was what me?”

“Did you turn it back?”

“I don’t remember touching it. Maybe you didn’t move it as far as you thought.”

“I watched it face the wall.”

Daniel set down the spoon. “I’m not accusing you of anything. It’s a camera, Claire. We can turn it off if it bothers you.”

The offer sounded generous, which made the silence that followed feel like ingratitude. Claire took the kettle from its base. Steam washed over her wrist.

“There’s an electrician coming,” he added. “Please let him into the basement. I left the service number by the telephone.”

“You said estimate.”

“Same thing, more or less.”

“Aren’t you supposed to be here?”

“I have a meeting I can’t move.” He kissed the side of her head. “You’re better with people anyway.”

She wanted to ask about the camera again. Instead she watched him fasten his cuffs, collect his keys, and leave.

At eight forty-seven she found the service number on a yellow square of paper beside the landline they never used. There was no company name, only a number and the word ELECTRICAL in Daniel’s careful capitals.

She put the paper in her pocket.

At nine fifteen, nobody had arrived.

At nine thirty, Evelyn knocked on the back door.

Claire opened it a few inches. Her neighbor stood on the step wearing dark jeans and a red cardigan, holding a small ceramic pot in both hands. A sprig of rosemary tilted out of the soil.

“I was hoping you’d tell me where the sun lands in the afternoon,” Evelyn said. “I haven’t worked out which of my windows are useful.”

Claire looked past her. The yards were separated by a narrow strip of grass and a low fence with a gate that had never latched properly. Evelyn had come through it without asking.

“The south side gets the most light,” Claire said.

“That’s what I thought. But you look as though you’ve been waiting for someone.”

“An electrician.”

“Oh, dreadful. Nothing makes a morning disappear faster than waiting for a tradesman.”

Evelyn’s fingers rested on the rim of the pot. She had a small pale scar beneath her thumb, nearly invisible against the white glaze.

“Would you like to come in?” Claire asked, surprising herself.

“Only for a minute.”

Evelyn wiped her shoes carefully and stepped inside. She looked at the blue cabinets, and Claire watched her look. Yesterday the woman had described their color from the front porch. Today her gaze moved without any sign of discovery, from the sink to the coffee maker to the camera above the mudroom door.

“Those are lovely,” Evelyn said. “You chose them?”

“Yes.”

“Of course you did. They’re not Daniel’s sort of blue.”

Claire felt her shoulders tighten. “You barely know him.”

Evelyn set the rosemary on the counter. “You can tell a little from the way someone dresses. That man would paint every room the same sensible gray if he could.”

Claire laughed before she meant to. Daniel had once suggested exactly that.

Evelyn caught the laugh and smiled, but did not press. “I suppose that’s an unfair thing to say about a man I’ve only met twice.”

“Probably.”

“Good. Tell me when I’m being unfair. I can take it.”

It was a strangely welcome invitation. Claire could not remember the last time Daniel had told her to correct him.

The doorbell rang. Claire put her hand over the yellow note in her pocket, then went to answer it.

A young man in work boots stood outside holding a tablet. On the side of his van was a company name Claire didn’t recognize. He identified himself as a subcontractor sent to look at an intermittent kitchen circuit and a basement access panel.

“Access panel?” Claire repeated.

He turned his tablet so she could read the job description. Much of the text was abbreviated. A few words stood out: LOW VOLTAGE, CONDUIT, VERIFY EXISTING.

“That’s what the ticket says,” he replied. “Could be nothing. The dispatcher sends us the notes.”

Daniel had mentioned wiring above the sink. He had said nothing about the basement.

“I need to call my husband,” Claire said.

“Sure. I can wait.”

Daniel answered on the fourth ring, sounding winded. In the background someone was speaking near a microphone.

“The man says there’s basement work.”

“Yes, I told you that.”

“You told me the light was flickering.”

“The wiring runs down through the basement. That’s why I asked you to let him in.”

“I didn’t hear that part.”

“Claire.” His voice dropped. “I’m in a conference room. Let him do his job, please.”

She looked through the glass at the electrician standing beside his van, shoulders hunched against the wind. A second person could have read the scene as a wife delaying a routine repair over a misunderstanding.

“I want the work order,” she said.

“What?”

“A copy of whatever he’s here to do.”

A moment passed. “Fine. Get the work order.”

Daniel ended the call without saying goodbye.

When Claire returned to the porch, the young man emailed her the ticket. He explained that he would inspect the visible connections first and wouldn’t open a wall without permission. She asked him to begin with the kitchen light. He looked relieved to have a simple instruction.

Evelyn was still at the counter when Claire came back. She had not touched her coffee; she was examining a postcard held beneath a refrigerator magnet. The postcard was from Claire’s sister in Maine.

“Your family lives far away?” Evelyn asked.

“My sister does.”

“That must be difficult when you need an extra pair of hands.”

Claire moved the postcard back under its magnet. “I manage.”

“I’m sure you do.” Evelyn stepped away. “I didn’t mean to pry.”

The apology was so immediate and unadorned that Claire found herself wanting to reassure her.

“It’s all right,” she said. “She’s busy with her boys. We talk.”

“Good.” Evelyn took up the rosemary pot. “I’ll stop distracting you. And if you need somewhere quiet while he works, come over. My kettle doesn’t shriek.”

After she left, Claire noticed that the camera’s light was off. She couldn’t remember whether it had been lit when Evelyn entered.

The electrician spent forty minutes checking the switch, the fixture, and a junction box accessible from the basement stairs. He found a loose connection in the fixture and tightened it. The light stopped flickering. When he mentioned the additional basement note, Claire asked him not to do anything else until she had spoken to the company.

“That’s your call,” he said. “I’ll mark it inspection only.”

He typed on the tablet in front of her. Claire waited for the email confirmation, then saved it in a folder she named HOUSE.

By noon, the air had turned wet and cold. Clouds hung low over the rooftops, and leaves skittered along the gutters. Claire ate half a sandwich at the kitchen table. At the other end lay the work order, an envelope addressed to Daniel, and an unopened bank statement she had found wedged behind the fruit bowl.

She did not open the envelope. She slid the statement toward herself, saw that it was addressed to both of them, and broke the seal.

Most of the figures were ordinary: the mortgage payment, a grocery charge, the pharmacy. But she couldn’t immediately place a transfer described only by a string of letters and numbers. She underlined it with a pencil, then looked at the date. Three weeks ago. The same week Daniel had called their vacation savings “temporarily committed.”

Before she could search further, her phone vibrated.

A message from Daniel: Hope the repair went smoothly. Please don’t let the bill turn into another project.

Claire stared at the words. She hadn’t told him there was a bill.

There might not be one. The electrician had said the office would invoice Daniel’s account. Daniel was probably referring to that. She could hear him saying so, patient and faintly amused, if she mentioned it tonight.

She put the phone facedown.

A second message arrived, this one from Evelyn.

I made too much soup. Would you like some tonight? No obligation.

Claire checked the clock. It was twelve thirteen. Evelyn must have seen the van leave, she thought. It would be natural to wonder whether a neighbor had eaten.

She typed: Thank you, but I think we’re having dinner together.

Evelyn answered immediately: Of course. I hope it’s a good evening.

Claire carried the bank statement upstairs and placed it between two old magazines on her bedside table. She disliked the furtiveness of the gesture. No one had told her she couldn’t read a statement with her name on it. Yet when she imagined Daniel seeing the penciled line, she could already hear him ask why she’d gone looking for trouble.

The trouble was that she couldn’t explain why she had underlined it without sounding as though she expected to find something wrong.

At four, Nora called.

Nora had known Claire since their first office job, before Daniel, before the house, before either woman had learned how to stretch a thirty-minute lunch into a full accounting of her life. She worked in the public library now and was calling from her car while the windshield wipers ticked steadily.

“You missed coffee,” she said.

Claire pressed her hand to her forehead. Their standing Wednesday coffee meeting. She had put it on the calendar, then spent the morning with the electrician.

“I forgot.”

“I gathered. I waited twenty minutes and bought a muffin in your honor.”

“I’m sorry.”

“You know you can just say you forgot, right?”

The words were so similar to Evelyn’s remark yesterday that Claire stiffened.

“Claire?”

“Sorry. I had someone at the house. And the new woman next door has been coming by.”

“Already? What’s she like?”

“Friendly.”

“That sounded like a warning label.”

Claire told her about the coffee and the rosemary and the soup. She did not mention the glass at first. Nora listened without interrupting.

“Has Daniel met her?” Nora asked.

“Yes. Apparently.”

“Apparently?”

“He says he did. She says she did. I wasn’t there.”

“Okay.” Nora paused as a horn sounded in the traffic behind her. “Do you like her?”

Claire looked at the kitchen window. Evelyn’s house stood across the strip of grass, its curtains closed against the gray afternoon.

“I don’t know yet.”

“That seems like a reasonable answer.”

Claire wanted to tell Nora about the camera, but the words felt disproportionate. She could already picture Nora arriving with a screwdriver and a firm opinion, both of which might be welcome, neither of which Claire was ready to ask for.

“How’s Daniel?” Nora asked instead.

“Busy.”

“That isn’t what I asked.”

Claire rubbed a thumb across the faint pencil indentation on the bank statement’s envelope. “He’s been tired.”

“And you?”

“Also tired.”

“Come by Saturday,” Nora said. “No agenda. I have a chair that needs no fixing and a bottle of wine that needs no justification.”

Claire smiled. “I’ll try.”

“Not try. Decide. You can decide things.”

When they hung up, Claire carried the phone downstairs. Outside, a man in a charcoal jacket emerged from Evelyn’s side door. He paused by the gate and spoke to someone Claire couldn’t see. His hand rested on the top rail, then he crossed to a dark sedan parked at the curb.

Claire saw only his profile before he got in. There was nothing remarkable about a neighbor having visitors. She kept watching until the car turned the corner.

At six thirty Daniel came home carrying a grocery bag and the expression he wore when he expected to be thanked for solving something.

“I brought the salmon you like,” he said. “Thought we could eat properly for once.”

Claire cleared the mail from the counter while he unpacked herbs, a lemon, and a small carton of cream. He kissed her cheek. She smelled rain on his coat and the clean metallic scent of the garage.

“The electrician fixed the light,” she said.

“Good.”

“He didn’t do the basement work.”

Daniel paused with the salmon in his hands. “Why not?”

“I asked for the details first.”

“We discussed this.”

“We discussed a light.”

“There are other parts of a house than the thing you can see.” He placed the fish on a plate with exaggerated care. “Do you want to manage all the repairs now? Because I can hand you the whole file.”

Claire almost said she didn’t. It would have ended the exchange. Instead she said, “I’d like to know what’s being repaired in my own house.”

Daniel looked at her for a moment. His face did not change much, but his voice grew soft.

“Of course you would. I’m only surprised that a simple appointment has made you feel shut out.”

It was an elegant turn. She had asked for information, and now the subject was her feeling. When she tried to explain the difference, he held up a hand.

“Let’s eat. We don’t need another unpleasant night.”

He began chopping herbs with efficient strokes. Claire set plates on the table and told herself that arguing during dinner would achieve nothing. It was what she often told herself. The phrasing felt worn smooth from use.

They ate by the window while rain tapped the glass. Daniel described a meeting, a colleague who talked too much, and an expensive proposal he believed would fail. He was funny when he wanted to be. Claire laughed at a story about a printer that had chewed through an entire stack of contracts. For fifteen minutes they were a couple with no mystery between them.

Then Daniel said, “Evelyn seems nice.”

Claire set down her fork. “You’ve spoken to her again?”

“She was outside when I got home.”

“I didn’t see you.”

“You were upstairs, I think.”

He cut another piece of salmon. “She said you had a rough morning.”

“What did she say?”

“Just that you seemed stressed. The electrician, probably.”

Claire looked toward the side window. Evelyn’s kitchen was lit by a single pendant lamp. No one stood within view.

“I wasn’t that stressed.”

“I didn’t say you were.”

“You said she told you I was.”

“Claire, please. She was being kind.” He took a drink of water. “You don’t need to interrogate every nice thing someone says about you.”

There was the familiar tightness, like a cord drawn around a room. Claire could respond to his criticism or continue asking about Evelyn. She couldn’t seem to do both.

“She hasn’t known me long enough to know whether I’m stressed,” she said.

Daniel sighed. “Then tell her that. I’m not going to referee a disagreement that doesn’t exist.”

After dinner he loaded the dishwasher and put the remaining salmon in a container. He offered to make tea. Claire said no. He made himself a cup, went into his study, and shut the door.

From the hallway she heard the rise and fall of his voice on a call. She couldn’t make out the words. She thought about standing closer, then hated the thought enough to leave.

At eight, someone tapped at the kitchen window.

Claire started so violently that the spoon in her hand struck the edge of her mug. Evelyn stood outside in a raincoat, smiling apologetically. She pointed toward the back door and held up a covered bowl.

Claire let her in only as far as the mudroom.

“I know you said no soup,” Evelyn said. “This is for tomorrow. It’s ridiculous to waste it.”

“You didn’t need to come out in the rain.”

“I wanted to bring the bowl back before I forgot.”

Claire took it. It was warm through the towel wrapped around it.

“Daniel says you had the electrician in,” Evelyn continued. “I hope he sorted the problem.”

“He fixed the light.”

“Good. It sounded as though you were worried about the basement.”

Claire looked up sharply. “What sounded that way?”

Evelyn’s smile faltered, almost imperceptibly. “Daniel mentioned there was more work to be done.”

“When?”

“Oh, sometime today. He was outside just before dinner.”

That was reasonable. It was also what Claire had heard from Daniel, and she was getting tired of reasonable explanations arriving one step ahead of her.

Evelyn shifted the strap of her raincoat. “Have I said something wrong?”

“No.”

“You can tell me.”

Claire thought of Nora telling her to decide things. She could ask Evelyn directly, and any ordinary person would answer.

“Yesterday,” Claire said, “you mentioned a broken glass.”

Evelyn nodded slowly.

“I didn’t tell you about that glass. How did you know?”

For a moment the only sound was the rain hitting the metal downspout.

“Did I say broken glass?” Evelyn asked.

“You did.”

“I’d forgotten.” Evelyn seemed to search her memory. “Daniel said you’d had one of those awful evenings where everything goes wrong. I must have mixed that up with something else. I broke a glass packing the kitchen myself.”

Claire examined her face. It held mild embarrassment, nothing more. If Evelyn was lying, she was doing it with extraordinary restraint. If she wasn’t, Claire had spent a day building meaning around a coincidence.

“I’m sorry,” Evelyn said. “I didn’t mean to make you uncomfortable.”

Claire shook her head. “No, I asked.”

“I’m glad you did.” Evelyn rested her hand on the doorframe. “You don’t have to guess what I mean. Ask me.”

She left before Claire could decide whether to thank her.

The bowl sat on the counter under its towel. Claire did not open it. She went instead to the hall and looked toward Daniel’s study, where a narrow bar of light showed beneath the door. She could hear a keyboard clicking. She almost knocked.

Her phone vibrated in her hand. A message from Evelyn.

Please don’t let my foolishness add to your evening. Sometimes the kindest thing is to leave a person in peace.

Claire read it twice. Then a third time, because the second sentence was almost exactly what Daniel had said to her after the argument over the broken glass: Sometimes the kindest thing you can do is leave me in peace.

She remembered because he had said it while she was picking pieces of glass off the kitchen floor. She had knelt with her back to him, holding a shard between her fingers. It was not a phrase he’d used before, not in all the years they’d lived together.

She opened the message thread and typed: Did Daniel tell you to say that?

Her thumb hovered above Send.

An ordinary neighbor might take offense. A guilty one might learn what Claire had noticed. Claire deleted the question.

Instead she wrote the sentence in the notes app, beneath the date and the time. She added the words from Daniel’s argument as she remembered them, putting a question mark beside the one word she couldn’t be sure of.

She looked up at the camera. Its blue light remained dark.

In the study, Daniel laughed softly at something on his screen.

Claire set the phone facedown and went to check whether the back door was locked. It was. She checked the latch twice anyway. Then she turned away from the kitchen, carrying the untouched bowl of soup upstairs.

CHAPTER THREE Things Claire Forgot

By Saturday morning, after two strained days of routine, the rain had stopped, leaving the driveway striped with wet leaves. Claire stood at the kitchen sink with a mug of coffee going cold in her hands and watched a delivery van negotiate the narrow turn at the end of Birch Lane. She had slept in fits. Whenever she closed her eyes, she saw the message on her phone and, behind the words, Daniel’s back as he walked away from the broken glass.

Sometimes the kindest thing is to leave a person in peace.

Evelyn had written it almost exactly. Not a dramatic sentence, not one Claire could hold up in a crowded room and expect everyone to gasp. People said similar things all the time. Daniel might have repeated it to his neighbor, perhaps casually, in a conversation about how hard the past few weeks had been. A husband was allowed to confide in someone. A neighbor was allowed to be awkwardly sympathetic.

Claire knew all the explanations. She was becoming very good at supplying them.

She opened the notes app. Beneath Wednesday’s entry she typed: Ask Daniel when he spoke to Evelyn about the glass. Then she looked at the sentence and took out the word ask. She didn’t want to rehearse the question so many times that she could no longer tell what she had thought before she asked it.

Upstairs the shower cut off. Daniel would come down soon, dressed for the Saturday errands he insisted they had agreed to do together. Claire remembered agreeing to collect paint samples for the upstairs hall. She did not remember agreeing to spend an entire Saturday shopping for things they didn’t need. They had had that discussion, or a version of it, over dinner on Wednesday.

The bowl Evelyn had brought lay untouched in the refrigerator. Claire had put it there near midnight, after considering leaving it on the counter long enough to justify throwing it away. The towel around it smelled faintly of rosemary. She moved it behind a carton of milk.

Daniel entered wearing a blue sweater and carrying his phone. He kissed the side of her head as he passed.

“Ready in twenty?” he asked.

“For what?”

He opened the refrigerator. “The lighting showroom. I sent you the address.”

“I’m going to Nora’s.”

He turned, milk carton in hand. “Today?”

“We talked about it yesterday.”

“Claire, we have an appointment at eleven.”

“With whom?”

“At the showroom. For the hall fixtures.”

“I didn’t make an appointment.”

“I did. And I told you.” His tone was level enough that she felt unreasonable before she knew why. “You said Saturday was fine.”

From the kitchen, Claire could see the calendar in the hall. Under SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 7, in Daniel’s tidy block handwriting, were the words LIGHTING — 11. She was certain she had glanced at it yesterday and seen only the recycling reminder. But certainty had become a poor instrument in this house.

“I don’t remember,” she said.

“That doesn’t mean we didn’t discuss it.”

“I know.”

Daniel set the milk down. “We can cancel if you need to. I just wish you’d tell me before I’m the one making the call.”

The remark placed a small debt in her hands. If she went, she would miss Nora. If she didn’t, she would be responsible for the inconvenience. It was an arrangement she understood so well she sometimes entered it without being asked.

“I’m still going to Nora’s,” she said. “I’m sorry about the appointment.”

He watched her. “There’s no need to apologize if you aren’t sorry.”

“I am sorry you have to cancel.”

“But not sorry you forgot.”

She took a breath. “I don’t know whether I forgot.”

For a moment Daniel looked more surprised than angry. Then he shrugged. “Fine. I’ll take care of it.”

He turned back to the refrigerator, searching for the cream. The conversation was finished because he had decided it was. Claire took her coffee into the hall, where the calendar hung beside the telephone alcove. She leaned closer. The appointment was written in black ink, as ordinary and solid as the rest of the week. A small arrow had been drawn beneath it, pointing to the following Monday: BASEMENT—CALL BACK.

She had not noticed that either.

She photographed the calendar with her phone. The impulse embarrassed her. Photographing a household calendar was the sort of thing people did in television dramas when they suspected an elaborate crime. She was not investigating a crime. She was trying to remember a conversation about light fixtures.

Yet she kept the picture.

At ten fifteen, Daniel called from the upstairs landing that he was leaving for the showroom anyway. “No point wasting the appointment,” he said. “I’ll look at options.”

Claire followed him to the door. “What company is it?”

He looked at her keys in her hand. “What?”

“The showroom. What’s it called?”

“Harbor Lighting. I sent the details.”

“Right.”

He kissed her cheek. “Have a nice afternoon.”

She stood at the window while his silver SUV backed down the drive. He waved without looking directly at the house. When he was gone, she searched her messages for Harbor Lighting. Nothing appeared. She tried showroom, lighting, fixtures. There were conversations about the dishwasher repair, a link to a restaurant menu, and an exchange in which she had reminded Daniel to buy furnace filters. No showroom address.

She checked her email. Nothing there either.

He could have sent it to an old account. He could have said it aloud while she was reading. Perhaps the calendar had been enough. Claire returned to the kitchen and found a stack of envelopes near the fruit bowl, all sorted by size. Daniel always sorted the mail. He also threw away the outer envelopes, which meant a document could lose its date of arrival before she had seen it.

She started separating the papers. An electric bill. A renewal notice for the homeowners’ policy. A folded bank statement addressed to both of them. The envelope bore a faint rectangle where a mailing label had been peeled away. She lifted the statement, then stopped.

They used electronic statements now. Daniel had said so in August, after their bank introduced a new account portal. This was another paper statement, despite what he had told her.

The sheet showed their household savings account and a balance she did not recognize. There was no catastrophic loss, no obvious theft. A transfer of $1,250 had left the account near the end of September. The description was abbreviated: ONLINE TRANSFER TO LINKED ACCT. The sum was large enough to make Claire sit down.

She took out her phone and opened their banking app. The account was listed, but the app asked her to verify an identity method she couldn’t complete without a code sent to Daniel’s phone. A message explained that the security settings had recently been updated.

“Recently,” she said aloud. The kitchen was silent.

Daniel had once shown her how to view the household accounts. He liked to point at the graphs and tell her they were doing well. She had liked knowing that he enjoyed managing the finances. Her own work had been less regular that year, and he had been proud of keeping their future orderly. Somewhere between one app update and another, she had become someone who needed to ask permission to see the figures.

She made a copy with her phone’s document scanner and saved it in the folder labeled HOUSE. Then she returned the original to the stack exactly where it had been. She did not yet know whether Daniel had moved money to pay an ordinary expense. He had never hidden the fact that they had other accounts. The amount might be part of a transfer he could explain in ten seconds.

What troubled her was not knowing how to check.

At ten fifty she drove to Nora’s, taking the long road past the small shopping center rather than the direct route along the railway. She wanted time to decide what she would say. She had spent much of her adult life making stories about her marriage smaller before allowing another person to hear them.

Nora lived in a brick duplex with deep green shutters and an aggressively untidy front garden. At the door she took one look at Claire and said, “You can have tea or wine. It’s eleven in the morning, so I recommend tea, but I’m flexible.”

“Tea.”

“Good. I made the cake you like, which is mostly lemon and bad decisions.”

Inside, the kitchen smelled of toasted sugar. Nora poured water into two mugs and set a plate of cake between them. She had been Claire’s friend since their first jobs after college, long enough to have seen Daniel at his most charming and Claire at her least guarded. She did not treat the marriage as a tragedy. That was one reason Claire had kept returning to her.

“You didn’t sound like yourself on Wednesday,” Nora said.

“I don’t think I know what that means anymore.”

Nora sat down. “Then tell me something specific.”

Claire told her about the appointment, the calendar entry, and the message from Evelyn. She left the bank statement for last. With each detail spoken aloud, she heard how easily it could be dismissed. People misremembered appointments. Neighbors repeated things. Married couples moved money without briefing one another every time.

Nora listened without interrupting. When Claire finished, she asked, “What would make you feel better about the appointment?”

“I want to know whether he really sent…

“T…

Preview complete

Keep reading The Neighbor Who Knew Everything

You've reached the end of the free preview. Purchase this eBook for permanent access in your Novel Thunder Library, or read it with an eligible Novel Thunder subscription.

Buy eBook — $5.99