Before the Storm Finds Usby Sloane Reed
×
Free PreviewRead the first 10% — no account required.
Before the Storm Finds Us cover
Preview

Chapter 1

The House at the End of the Road

The road into Blackwater Cove still bent toward the sea as though it had been built by someone trying to escape it.

Avery Bennett recognized the turn before she saw the faded sign. On the right, pines crowded a slope of rust-colored sand. On the left, the marsh opened into a flat, silver distance, the water cut by grasses and the narrow black tracks of tidal creeks. The highway smelled of wet earth through the vents of her car. She had forgotten that smell. Or she'd taught herself to.

BLACKWATER COVE — POP. 4,812.

Someone had painted a fresh blue wave beneath the numbers. The sign had been crooked when she was twenty-three, and it was crooked now.

She slowed. The driver behind her leaned on the horn. Avery pulled onto the shoulder, let a landscaping truck pass, and stayed there long enough to make the engine tick impatiently.

Eight years. She'd counted them in apartments, promotions, birthdays politely acknowledged by voicemail. She had not counted them in missed funerals. Her father had arranged to make this the first.

Her phone lit up in the console. Lila Morgan. Third call since Avery had crossed the county line.

Avery pressed the steering-wheel button. “I'm here.”

“You mean the county, or you actually made it to town?”

“Technically both.”

“Good. Because I've spent an hour keeping Mrs. Halpern from moving your flowers to a different table.” Lila spoke briskly, as if a funeral were a café shift that could be rescued by better staffing. “The service starts in forty minutes. I left a sandwich at the church office. And you don't have to talk to anybody you don't want to.”

“That last part sounds unlikely.”

“Then don't talk to anybody you don't like.”

“A shorter list.”

Silence filled the car. It was the first pause Lila had allowed since she called with the news three days ago.

“Av,” she said, softer now. “Are you okay to drive?”

Avery watched a white egret rise from the ditch and clear the road with lazy, offended wings. “I'm fine.”

“That's not what I asked.”

“It’s the answer I've got.”

Lila exhaled. “All right. I'll meet you by the side entrance.”

The line clicked off. Avery looked at her own face in the rearview mirror: dark hair caught in a low knot, concealer doing a reasonable job of hiding a sleepless night, the same hazel eyes her father once called too observant for her own good. She tucked a loose strand behind one ear and merged back onto the road.

The church sat two blocks from the harbor, white clapboard bright against the low gray sky. At the curb, a line of cars already stretched toward the post office. The town had shown up for Thomas Bennett. Whether it had come to mourn him or to get another look at his daughter was a question Avery couldn't answer.

Lila waited by the side door in a navy dress and scuffed flats, her blond hair pinned back with a pencil. She stepped down before Avery had fully parked.

“You look exhausted,” she said, and pulled Avery into a hug.

“Thank you. You look like someone who threatened a florist.”

“I did threaten a florist.” Lila held her at arm's length. “I also brought coffee. Don't be proud.”

Avery took the paper cup. Her hands were cold enough that the heat stung. “Where's the sandwich?”

“Right where you'll ignore it.”

They went inside together. The church smelled of lilies, lemon polish, and old hymnals. People turned when Avery passed, then looked away a fraction too late. She knew some of their faces and couldn't put names to them. Others she knew with unpleasant precision: the former guidance counselor who'd told her to concentrate on the future; the insurance adjuster who'd sat at her kitchen table while her father insisted there must be a mistake; a man whose son had died in the marina fire.

He stood beside the third pew with his wife. Avery's steps faltered. The man's gaze passed over her without acknowledgment. Somehow that was worse than anger.

Lila touched her elbow, not guiding, simply there.

At the front, the photograph of her father showed him before the weight loss, squinting into the sunlight beside a skiff he'd repaired himself. In the picture he was laughing at something outside the frame. Avery could remember taking it. She could remember refusing to tell him what was funny.

What she could not remember was their last conversation without anger in it.

The minister began. Thomas had been dependable, he said. He had repaired boats in weather nobody else would go out in. He'd checked on neighbors after storms. He'd raised two children through loss. There was no mention of Ethan's case, of the marina, of the years Thomas spent working alone with a manila folder always within reach.

Avery listened to the descriptions of a father everyone seemed to have known except her. The final hymn rose around her. She kept her mouth closed.

Afterward, people approached in careful increments. They touched her wrist and said they were sorry. Some asked whether she was still in Charlotte. Two asked if she planned to sell the house. One woman told her that time healed everything, then seemed offended when Avery did not agree.

She was trying to escape to the coatroom when a man in a charcoal suit intercepted her near the door. His silver hair was neatly combed; he held his umbrella by the polished wooden handle.

“Miss Bennett,” he said. “Richard Vale. I don't imagine you remember me.”

She remembered him. He had been younger at the pretrial hearing, his tie a brighter shade of red. He'd testified that his company had no involvement in marina operations. Her father had gripped the bench hard enough to whiten his knuckles.

“Mr. Vale.”

“Your father was a good man.” His expression held the practiced gravity of someone who gave condolences often. “We didn't always see eye to eye. But this town owes him a great deal.”

“Thank you.”

His gaze flicked toward the crowd. “I understand you're handling the estate. If you need assistance navigating local matters, my office can help.”

“That's kind.”

“I mean it.” He reached into his coat and offered a card. Embossed lettering, thick stock. “There are decisions you'll have to make. No need to make them alone.”

Avery took it because refusing would attract more attention. “I'll keep that in mind.”

“I hope you do.” Vale's smile remained when his eyes moved past her. “Take care of yourself in that old house. It's been empty for a while.”

The words were ordinary. She had the distinct impression he'd selected each one.

Lila appeared at her shoulder carrying Avery's black coat. “Sorry, Richard. I have to steal her.”

“Of course.” He stepped aside. “My condolences again.”

Outside, the wind had turned sharp. Lila waited until they reached the car before speaking.

“Don't let him make this about real estate today.”

“He already tried.”

“That man could find a sales opportunity at the bottom of the ocean.”

Avery opened the driver's door. “I think he'd make sure he owned the ocean first.”

Lila's laugh came out too fast. “Come by the café tonight. I'll put something together.”

“I might just go to the house.”

“Then I can bring it there.”

“Lila.”

“All right. I'll stop mothering you for approximately three hours.” She sobered. “Call if it's bad, okay?”

Avery knew Lila meant the house, the memories, the lonely rooms. She nodded anyway.

She did not tell her oldest friend that she had come prepared to stay only six nights.

The house stood at the end of Breakwater Road, still listed as Marsh Point Road on the deed, where the asphalt narrowed to one lane and the trees made a tunnel above it. Its weathered blue siding had gone almost gray. The porch sagged a little at the eastern corner, and sea oats pushed up along the steps. A cedar tree had grown into the fence since she'd last been there.

Avery killed the engine but didn't move. Beyond the house, she could hear the surf. The place had always sat just far enough back from the water to pretend it was safe.

On the front door hung a small brass bell in the shape of a fish. Her mother had bought it at a craft fair when Avery was eleven. Wind moved the bell gently against the wood.

The key Lila had left with the funeral papers resisted the lock. Avery turned it harder. The door opened with a sticky pull, releasing a pocket of air that smelled of dust, cedar, and the faint bitter trace of her father's coffee.

She stepped into the hallway. The framed watercolor of the harbor still hung above the narrow table. The umbrella stand still held two bent fishing rods and a walking stick nobody used. Her father's boots stood heel to heel beneath the coat hooks. He had apparently taken them off one final time, expecting to put them on again.

Avery set her bag down carefully. The quiet pressed in around her.

“Hello?” she called, then felt foolish.

There was no answer. The refrigerator hummed in the kitchen. Something tapped in the wall as a pipe settled.

She opened the curtains, one room at a time. Pale afternoon light fell over a sofa with a patched arm, the stack of maritime magazines on the end table, a faded afghan her mother had crocheted in a pattern she never managed to teach Avery. Books crowded the shelves in uneven rows. On top sat a framed school photograph of Ethan, eighteen and grinning, before the years made him look older than his father.

Avery turned the picture facedown. Immediately she hated herself for doing it. She turned it back.

The lawyer's envelope lay on the kitchen table exactly where Lila said it would be. Avery took off her coat, poured herself a glass of water from the tap, and unfolded the papers. The will was short. House, property, personal effects: all to Avery. Ethan received a modest trust, established long before his imprisonment and administered separately. The attorney's cover letter referred to a prior conversation her father had requested and never completed.

Behind the will sat a smaller envelope with her name written in Thomas Bennett's careful block capitals.

AVERY.

She ran her thumb over the ridge made by the pen. Once, when she was little, he'd written her name on the inside of every rain boot and coat collar. After the fire, his letters had become brief, formal documents disguised as family correspondence. He'd asked about her work. She'd answered. Neither of them had mentioned the thing between them.

Inside was a single sheet torn from a yellow legal pad.

I know I waited too long. The fire didn't start where they said it did. Don't sell the house. Find what I left you.

No signature. No explanation.

Avery read it twice and then a third time, more slowly. Her father had spent eight years insisting Ethan hadn't set the fire. He had given the insistence every shape grief could take: pleas, arguments, brittle silences. Avery had heard the same claims so often that eventually she had stopped hearing them at all.

This was different. Not Ethan didn't do it . A claim about where the fire had started. A detail that could be tested.

She reached for her phone, then stopped. Whom would she call? The attorney who had told her the estate was uncomplicated? Ethan, whose first weeks out of prison had been marked by unanswered texts from her? Noah—

No. Absolutely not Noah.

She folded the note along its original crease and slipped it into her bag.

A dull thump came from upstairs.

Avery stood still. The house was old; she knew the noises it made. Boards popped when the temperature dropped. Windows complained in a hard wind. This sound had weight behind it, like a drawer closing.

“Who's there?”

She waited. The refrigerator clicked off. The silence seemed to deepen.

Avery took the kitchen's heavy flashlight from its hook and climbed the stairs. She wasn't frightened, she told herself. Not yet. She was irritated at the possibility that the raccoons her father used to fight had returned to the attic.

Her old bedroom door stood open. Inside, the quilt was neatly folded, and a cardboard box of school trophies rested against the wall. The guest room held a bare mattress and a stack of folded drop cloths. At the end of the hall, the door to her father's room was ajar.

She had left it closed when she arrived. She was almost certain.

“Hello?”

No answer.

She pushed the door wide. The bed had been stripped. There were pale rectangles on the walls where pictures had hung and a dustless patch on the dresser where his watch must have sat. The closet doors were closed.

Avery swept the flashlight across the floor. Near the window was a scatter of dried mud, fine and orange-brown, unmistakable against the old hardwood. The screen latch was bent outward. She crossed to it, careful not to step in the dirt. The window was locked, but the lower edge of the screen hung loose.

Her father had not been capable of opening this window during his final months. Lila told her he'd barely managed the stairs.

Avery photographed the mud and the damaged latch. Then she pulled the closet doors open, one after the other, and found only empty hangers, a folded blanket, and a hard-sided suitcase.

She looked beneath the bed. Nothing.

The noise came again, this time from beyond the wall. A scrape, a rattle, and a soft impact.

Avery turned sharply. The sound belonged to the house's narrow service attic. Her father had installed a vent there years ago, after discovering mold behind the insulation. Wind could lift the loose metal flap, making it knock against its frame.

She opened the attic access in the hall and shone the light inside. A sliver of daylight showed around the vent. The flap struck again, and some tension drained out of her shoulders.

Then the flashlight beam found a fresh shoeprint in dust on the plywood directly below the opening.

Avery held the light steady. The tread was broad, with a deep diagonal pattern. Beyond it, a clean drag mark crossed the dust toward a stack of boxes.

She did not climb in.

Back downstairs, she locked the front door and checked the kitchen entrance. Its dead bolt caught, but the knob turned farther than she expected. The strike plate had been loosened; one screw protruded at an angle. She took a photograph of that too.

She dialed the nonemergency number posted on the refrigerator. After several rings, a dispatcher answered. Avery described the disturbed window screen, the mud, the footprints, and the loose back-door plate. The dispatcher took her name and said a deputy would call when one was available.

“Was anything stolen?” the woman asked.

“I don't know yet. My father died. I've just come back.”

A pause. “I'm sorry for your loss, Ms. Bennett.”

Avery could hear a keyboard clicking at the other end. “Thank you.”

“Can you stay somewhere else tonight?”

“I can.” She looked toward the hall where her suitcase stood. “But I'd prefer not to.”

“Keep the doors locked. If anyone returns, call nine-one-one. Don't confront them.”

She hung up and waited for the sense of relief that ought to follow doing the sensible thing. It didn't come.

By dusk the sky had flattened to pewter. Avery made tea in a chipped mug and carried it to the living room, where she opened her laptop to review the estate inventory. Her professional life ran on schedules: surveys, permits, structural reports, contractors who needed answers by noon. She knew how to restore a building by identifying what could be saved and what had to come out. The house was an inheritance, not a resurrection. She would document it, hire someone to inspect the foundations, list it with a local agent, and go back to Charlotte.

Her father's note lay on the coffee table, no longer tucked safely in her bag. She had taken it out without admitting to herself why.

Find what I left you.

She rose and searched the desk in the living room. Most of its drawers held rubber bands, expired warranties, and pens that no longer worked. The bottom drawer was locked. She found a ring of keys hanging behind the pantry door, tried each small brass one, and got nowhere.

Somewhere outside, tires rolled slowly over gravel.

Avery moved to the window and lifted the curtain a fraction. A dark pickup stood at the bend in Breakwater Road, its headlights off. She could not see the driver. After a moment, the truck eased forward and disappeared around the trees.

It might have been a neighbor turning around. There were few reasons to come down this road unless you lived here.

She let the curtain fall.

At seven, Lila texted a picture of a covered takeout container and a question mark. Avery replied that she had eaten. This was a lie; she had consumed half a sleeve of crackers and enough coffee to make her stomach ache. Lila sent back a skeptical face and a red heart.

At eight-fifteen, the deputy called. He apologized for the delay. There had been an accident on the causeway, and he couldn't get to her until morning unless she believed someone was currently on the property. Avery told him no, not currently. He asked her to leave the scene undisturbed. She promised she would.

It began raining soon afterward, a soft, steady patter at the roofline. From the kitchen she could see the back porch light turning the wet railing a dull gold. She checked the dead bolt again, wedged a wooden chair beneath the knob, and moved through the downstairs rooms switching lamps on.

She told herself there was no shame in being cautious. She also told herself that a house could feel occupied simply because it was full of someone else's things.

At ten-thirty she carried her suitcase to her childhood bedroom. The mattress smelled clean, and the blanket was one Lila must have brought over. Avery left the hall light on. She changed into an old sweatshirt, washed her face, and sat on the edge of the bed with her phone.

An unsent message to Ethan waited in the thread from the day of his release: I'd like to see you when you're ready. She had composed it and then decided that “when you're ready” sounded like an accusation. So she'd written nothing instead.

She tried again.

I'm at the house. Dad left me a note about the fire. Can we talk tomorrow?

She read the message until the words seemed both too blunt and too weak. Then she sent it before she could stop herself.

The response did not arrive.

She lay down. Rain stroked the roof. A car passed on the distant road. She turned onto her side and watched the shadows move across the bedroom ceiling whenever wind pressed the branches against the window.

Something clicked against the glass.

She opened her eyes fully.

There it was again: a small hard tap, not the scrape of a twig. Her window faced the overgrown eastern side yard. The nearest tree stood well beyond reach.

Avery slipped out of bed without turning on the lamp. The room was cold against her bare feet. She moved to the wall beside the window and leaned just far enough to look out.

A figure stood in the grass below.

Not close enough for a face. Close enough that she could tell the person was looking straight up at her room. They wore a dark jacket with the hood raised. Rain shone on the shoulders. Their hands hung at their sides.

For a second Avery could not make herself move. She thought of the fresh footprint in the attic, the damaged back door, the pickup without headlights. She thought of how long someone might have been coming here while her father grew too ill to notice.

Then she reached across the curtain and snapped on the bedside lamp.

The yard burst into a wedge of yellow light. The figure stepped backward, turned, and ran toward the cedar fence. Branches shook. By the time Avery forced the window up, only the rain was moving.

“Hey!” she shouted into the dark.

Her voice sounded thin beneath the weather. No one answered.

She shut the window and called nine-one-one, giving her name and the address. A dispatcher instructed her to stay inside and away from the windows. Avery went downstairs with her phone against her ear. She kept the flashlight pointed at the floor so the beam wouldn't make her visible from outside.

The front door stood closed. The dead bolt remained turned. But beneath it, a pale corner of paper had appeared on the welcome mat.

Avery stopped halfway down the hall.

She was sure it had not been there when she checked the lock. She could see the paper clearly now, a folded white square pushed beneath the door far enough to clear the threshold.

The dispatcher was asking whether she could hear anything outside.

“No,” Avery whispered. Then, after a moment: “Someone left something.”

“Please don't touch it. Officers are on their way.”

Avery crouched, keeping a careful distance. The paper had opened slightly as it slid across the floor. There was writing on the exposed fold, in black block capitals, four words she could read from where she stood.

YOUR FATHER SHOULD HAVE

Avery's pulse beat in her throat. She moved no closer. A draft from beneath the door lifted the free corner of the note, revealing the final two words.

STOPPED DIGGING.

The house seemed to shrink around her. Beyond the locked door, rain rattled against the fish-shaped bell, making it sound once, softly, like someone announcing an arrival.

Chapter 2

The Man She Left Behind

The first officer arrived nine minutes after Avery called. She knew because she had spent every one of those minutes watching the clock on the microwave, its green numbers advancing with an indifference that made her want to smash it.

When the cruiser lights flashed blue against the dining room curtains, she opened the door only as far as the chain allowed.

“Avery Bennett?”

The woman on the porch was in her late forties, rain dripping from the brim of her sheriff’s department cap. Her hand rested near her belt but not on her weapon. Behind her, a younger deputy shone a flashlight along the porch railing.

“Sheriff Mercer,” the woman said. “You can leave the chain on until you see my badge.”

Avery did. Then she unfastened the chain and stepped aside.

Dana Mercer had been a patrol deputy when Avery left Blackwater Cove. Avery remembered her as the officer who had driven Ethan home one night after a fight outside a bar and stayed long enough to make sure he had ice for his split lip. She remembered, too, seeing Mercer in the courtroom during Ethan’s sentencing, standing at the back with her hands folded.

“I’m sorry about your father,” Mercer said as she entered.

“Thank you.” Avery glanced at the doorway. “The note’s there. The dispatcher told me not to touch it.”

“You did the right thing.” Mercer crouched at the mat without crossing over the paper. “Deputy Phelps will photograph it and collect it. Walk me through what happened.”

Avery began with the tapping at the bedroom window. She described the hooded figure, the direction it ran, the note. She left out nothing, though saying each detail aloud made her feel foolish in a way the experience itself had not. The person outside might have been a teenager with a taste for cruel jokes. The scrape at the door could have been the wind. The four words on the paper were still just four words.

Mercer listened without interrupting. “And you mentioned signs of entry earlier?”

“A new footprint in the attic. Damage to the back door.”

“Did you photograph either?”

“The footprint, yes. On my phone.”

Mercer examined the picture. “You’re certain it isn’t yours?”

“My shoes weren’t muddy. And I only went into the attic after I noticed it.”

“That doesn’t establish when it got there.”

“I know.” Avery heard how sharp her voice sounded. “I’m not asking you to arrest somebody over a footprint.”

“I didn’t say you were.” Mercer handed back the phone. “I’m trying to separate what we know from what we suspect.”

Outside, Phelps spoke into his radio. A searchlight swept across the side yard and paused on the cedar fence. Mercer asked whether Avery had noticed a vehicle, and Avery told her about the pickup she had seen without its headlights on the road earlier that evening.

“Color?”

“Dark. Maybe green. Maybe blue. I was looking through rain.”

“Make and model?”

“No.”

“Anything about the driver?”

“I couldn’t see one.”

Mercer made a note. “You been back in town long?”

“Since this morning.”

“That’s fast for someone to know you’re here.”

Avery looked at the sheriff. “Exactly.”

Mercer held her gaze for a moment, then shut her notebook. “I’ll put extra patrols along this road tonight. I’d also like you to stay somewhere else if you can. A motel, a friend’s place. At least until we’ve had a daylight look around.”

“This is my house.”

“And you can be in your house tomorrow. Tonight I’d rather you were somewhere with working exterior lights and neighbors who can hear you yell.”

The bluntness made Avery like her a little. It did not make the suggestion any easier to accept.

“I’ll think about it,” she said.

Mercer exhaled through her nose. “Your father ever mention someone threatening him?”

“No. He stopped telling me much of anything.”

The sheriff’s expression changed, subtly enough that Avery might have imagined it. “He came to see me once,” Mercer said. “About six weeks ago.”

Avery gripped the edge of the table. “About what?”

“He wanted to revisit some details from the old marina fire. I told him the case had been closed years ago and that any new information needed to be specific.”

“Did he have new information?”

“He said he was working on it.”

“And you didn’t tell me this when I called about someone outside my window?”

“I’m telling you now. I can’t connect his visit to a person in your yard without evidence.”

Mercer’s refusal to leap to conclusions would have been reassuring if Avery had not spent eight years watching people refuse to question the conclusion they had reached about Ethan.

At the door, the sheriff paused. “Don’t open it to anybody you aren’t expecting. I’ll call in the morning.”

“What did you think when my father came to you?” Avery asked.

Mercer looked out toward the cruiser. “I thought he was a man who’d spent too long trying to change something he couldn’t live with.”

“That isn’t an answer.”

“No,” Mercer said. “It isn’t.”

The deputies left at half past one. Avery pushed an armchair beneath the front window and sat there with the lights off, watching the drive until the first colorless strip of dawn appeared over the marsh. She did not sleep.

By seven, the storm had eased into a damp, windless quiet. The gravel was littered with pine needles. Water hung from the porch roof in beads that fell one at a time. Avery made coffee from a tin she found in the freezer, tasted it, and poured it into the sink.

On the kitchen counter lay the cardboard folder the funeral director had given her: death certificates, a receipt for the service, the small photograph chosen for the memorial display. Her father stood on the old dock in shirtsleeves, laughing at something outside the frame. He was younger in the photograph than Avery was now.

She took her phone and called Lila Morgan.

Lila answered on the fourth ring, amid the clatter of dishes. “Please tell me you’re not calling because you changed your mind about coming by. I made enough cinnamon rolls to feed a fishing crew.”

“Someone came to the house last night.”

The clatter stopped. “What?”

Avery described the figure, the note, the sheriff. Lila listened without making the soothing noises people made when they wanted a frightened person to stop talking.

“Come into town,” Lila said at last. “Now. You can sit in my office until I close.”

“I need to get something to eat. And I want to look at the marina.”

“Why the marina?”

“Dad went to see the sheriff about the fire. Six weeks ago.”

There was a faint click on Lila’s end, as though she had set down a cup too hard.

“Lila?”

“I heard you. Just—be careful about talking to people down there. Everybody has an opinion about the Bennett family, and most of them haven’t improved with age.”

“People have always had opinions.”

“Not everybody means you well, Ave.”

Avery stared through the kitchen window toward the strip of water visible beyond the cedars. “I’m beginning to understand that.”

She put on jeans, a white sweater, and the waterproof jacket she kept in her car for site visits. At the hall mirror she tried to flatten the curl at her temple. There were gray shadows beneath her eyes. She looked like a woman who had spent the night getting acquainted with fear.

Blackwater Cove was smaller than memory and more polished. The bait shack near the causeway had become a coffee shop with reclaimed-wood benches. Two beachfront cottages wore fresh white siding and vacation-rental signs. A painted mural of a heron covered the brick wall where teenagers used to meet after dark. Across from the post office, the pharmacy had closed.

Yet the smell was the same: brine, wet rope, diesel, and the faint sweet rot of marsh grass. It came through the ventilation vents and caught at some place beneath Avery’s ribs.

She parked on Bay Street near the public pier. Her first instinct was to check whether anyone had followed her. She watched the rearview mirror until the truck behind her pulled into a loading zone and a man began hauling crates onto the sidewalk.

The waterfront had changed most of all. A high fence enclosed the stretch where the Bennett marina once stood. Beyond it, old pilings rose from the tidal water like blackened teeth. Fresh survey stakes marked the edge of the vacant lot. A billboard showed a rendering of glass-fronted condominiums above the words VALE HARBOR: A NEW CHAPTER FOR THE COVE.

Avery had seen the development online, years ago, and closed the page before reading it. In person, the billboard seemed less a proposal than a declaration of ownership.

She walked toward the chain-link gate. A laminated sign warned against trespassing. Someone had tied a length of red ribbon around one of the lower wires; it twisted in the wind like a wound that refused to close.

“Gate’s locked.”

The voice came from behind her.

She knew it before she turned. Not because it was unchanged—it was lower now, with a roughness at the edges—but because her body recognized it more quickly than her mind could prepare.

Noah Callahan stood six feet away in a navy rescue-service jacket, one hand wrapped around the handle of a travel mug. His dark hair was damp, and there was a faint white scar along his jaw she did not remember. He had always been broad across the shoulders. At thirty-four, he looked less like the boy who used to dive from the pier and more like a man whose work had taught him the cost of a bad decision.

“Avery.”

“Noah.”

For a moment they stayed where they were, separated by the width of a sidewalk and eight years of silence.

He glanced at the fence. “Didn’t figure you’d come here first.”

“I didn’t.”

“Right.” His mouth shifted, not quite a smile. “Your dad’s service was yesterday. I should’ve said I was sorry.”

“You weren’t there.”

“I was on duty.”

“Okay.”

She hated that she sounded as if she were scoring points. She hated more that she had noticed his absence at the funeral, even while telling herself she had no right to expect him.

Noah set his mug on a piling cap. “I heard about someone coming onto your property last night.”

“Is there anyone in this town who hasn’t?”

“Probably a few. Mercer called our dispatcher to ask whether the rescue team had seen anyone on the marsh road.”

“Did you?”

“No. We had a boat out until eleven, but nobody reported a person on shore.” He looked at her closely. “Are you all right?”

The question was simple. It nearly undid her.

“I’m tired.”

“I can see that.”

“Then why ask?”

“Because tired and all right aren’t the same thing.”

She turned back toward the fence. “I’m fine.”

“No, you’re not.”

Avery faced him again. “We’ve been talking for less than two minutes. You don’t get to decide what I am.”

Something tightened near his eyes. “You’re right.”

She expected him to argue. The lack of resistance left her without a place to put her anger.

Noah picked up his coffee. His left hand bore a thin band of pale skin where a ring might have been; when she realized what she was studying, she looked away. He noticed. Of course he did.

“Been back long?” he asked.

“One day.”

“Leaving soon?”

“That was the plan.”

“And now?”

“I have things to sort out.”

“Your father’s place?”

“Among other things.”

Noah nodded toward the billboard. “Vale’s people have been surveying the entire shoreline for months. I thought you should know before somebody comes to the house with a checkbook.”

“Why would he need our land?”

“Access. Parking. Water frontage. Depends on which version of the plan he’s selling.”

Avery studied the new stakes. “That fence is inside the old marina boundary.”

“Far as I know.”

“The retaining wall wasn’t stable even before the fire. There’s no way they’ve got clearance to build that close to the water without a full structural review.”

“You’d know more about that than I would.”

She looked at him. “You remember what I do?”

“I’ve seen your work.”

“How?”

“Your company restored that courthouse in Concord. It made the papers.”

She had been proud of the courthouse project: two years of painstaking research, salvaged stonework, contractors who had argued over every historically accurate hinge. She pictured Noah reading about it, perhaps at this very waterfront, and felt an ache so sudden she had to concentrate on the rusted fence links.

“You kept track of me?” she asked.

“Not regularly.” He looked out at the bay. “Sometimes a person’s name shows up, and you read the article.”

“Right.”

Silence opened again. Somewhere beyond the pier, gulls wheeled over a shrimp boat heading out to sea. A truck reversed near the fish market, emitting three thin electronic beeps.

“I’m sorry about your father,” Noah said again, softer this time. “He fixed the engine on my first truck. Wouldn’t take money. Just told me to quit driving like an idiot.”

Despite herself, Avery smiled. “He said that to everybody.”

“He meant it most with me.”

“He probably did.”

For half a second it was easy: the two of them recalling a man they had both loved. Then she remembered her father sitting alone at the kitchen table as coverage of Ethan’s sentencing replayed on the television. She remembered the last phone conversation, when he’d asked whether she planned to come for Christmas and she’d said she couldn’t promise anything.

Noah’s face changed when he saw her expression.

“You don’t have to do this here,” he said.

“Do what?”

“Stand in front of the place that ruined your family because you think you owe it a confrontation.”

Avery felt the old anger rise. “You don’t get to tell me why I’m standing here, either.”

“Fair enough.”

He took a step toward the street, then stopped. “I heard you found a note.”

She folded her arms. “Mercer tell you that too?”

“No. Lila texted me.”

“Lila had no business—”

“She was worried. That’s all.”

“Everybody in this town was apparently born worried about me.”

“No.” Noah’s voice sharpened. “Some of us learned it.”

The words landed between them harder than either had intended. His expression closed at once, and Avery saw the boy he had been on the night she left: standing at her car door, asking her to wait until morning before making any decisions.

She had driven away anyway.

“I didn’t come back to fight with you,” she said.

“Good. I didn’t come down here to fight with you either.”

“Then why are you here?”

“I’m heading to the station.” He indicated the low building at the pier’s far end. “That’s where I work.”

Of course it was. She had walked directly into his morning and acted as if he had followed her there.

Avery rubbed a hand over her face. “Sorry.”

Noah looked surprised enough that she nearly took the apology back.

“Don’t worry about it.”

“I’m not used to being back.”

“I can tell.”

His voice was gentler, and that made things worse. It would have been easier if he were cruel. If he had grown indifferent. If the years had erased the faint freckle near his left eye and the habit of waiting a beat before answering a question that mattered.

A gust carried a sprinkle of cold water off the rail. Avery pulled her jacket closed.

“Whoever was at the house,” Noah said, “did they try to get inside?”

“I found signs somebody had been in before. I don’t know whether it was the same person.”

“Mercer’s looking into it?”

“Yes.”

“Good.” He glanced at her car across the street. “You staying there tonight?”

“I haven’t decided.”

“There’s a motion light over the back door. Your father called me in September because it wasn’t working. I fixed it, but the wiring was old.”

Avery stared at him. “You went to the house?”

“He asked for help.”

“He didn’t tell me.”

“We weren’t exactly comparing calendars.”

“No.” She let out a breath. “No, we weren’t.”

She wanted to ask how often he’d visited. Whether her father had spoken about her. Whether Noah had stood in the kitchen and seen the empty chair where she used to sit. Instead she said, “Thank you for fixing the light.”

“It may need replacing. I could take another look if you want.”

“I can hire an electrician.”

“I know you can.”

The simple acknowledgment quieted something in her. He wasn't offering because he thought she was helpless. He was offering because he knew the house and because offering help was what Noah did, even when it cost him.

For years, she had told herself she left because she could not bear another day of being looked at as Ethan Bennett's sister. But there had been a second reason, one harder to admit: she had been terrified that if she stayed with Noah, one day he would look at her with the same disappointment she saw in everybody else's eyes.

She stepped away from the fence. “I should go.”

“Avery.”

She stopped.

His gaze flicked toward the parking area across the road. “Have you seen a dark green pickup around the house?”

A cold thread moved down her spine. “Why?”

“Just answer me.”

“I saw a dark pickup last night. I told the sheriff. Why are you asking?”

He hesitated. It was brief, but she knew him well enough to see it.

“Somebody stopped by the rescue station yesterday,” he said. “A man I didn't recognize. Late forties, maybe. Wore a ball cap pulled low. Asked if I knew whether you'd come back for good.”

Avery felt the noise of the waterfront retreat, as if somebody had closed a door between her and the town.

“What did you say?”

“That it wasn't his business.”

“And he just left?”

“Pretty much. There was a pickup in the lot, dark green, older Ford. I couldn't say for sure it was his. I didn't see him get into it.”

“Did he give you a name?”

“No.”

“Why didn't you tell Mercer?”

“Because until you mentioned a vehicle, I didn't know it mattered. I called her this morning after she contacted dispatch. She's got what I know.”

Avery looked at the cars parked along Bay Street. A silver SUV. A delivery van. Two sedans with salt dried along their doors. Every windshield seemed suddenly capable of hiding someone watching her.

“Did he ask anything else?”

Noah held her eyes. “He asked whether you'd been inside the house yet.”

The air left her lungs in a thin, soundless rush.

“Yesterday?”

“Just before lunch.”

She thought of the funeral flowers in the front room. The attic footprint. The paper under the door. Someone had been interested in whether she had entered her father's house before she had even finished standing beside his grave.

“Why would somebody ask you?” she said.

Noah's expression was unreadable. “Maybe he knew I used to know you.”

“Everybody used to know everybody in this town.”

“Not like we did.”

She looked away first.

“I'm going to call Mercer,” he said. “Tell her we talked and make sure she's got the details.”

“I can call her.”

“I know.” He pulled out his phone but made no move to dial. “If you go back out to the house, would you at least let somebody know you got there?”

Avery almost said she didn't need someone monitoring her movements. Almost. Then she remembered standing beside the bedroom window while a stranger watched from the grass.

“I'll text Lila,” she said.

Noah nodded, accepting what she offered rather than bargaining for more.

She walked away before either of them could speak again. She crossed the street with her shoulders square, as though a straight spine could keep the past from catching up. In the car she locked the doors, then laughed once, without humor, at the instinct.

Her phone buzzed before she started the engine.

A message from Lila: I told Noah what happened. Don't be mad. He knows that property better than anybody and I wanted another set of eyes on you.

Avery typed, You shouldn't have done that. She stared at the words, then deleted them.

Instead she wrote, I'm coming by the café.

As she pulled from the curb, she checked the mirror. Noah stood near the station door, talking into his phone. He watched her car move into traffic. For one foolish, piercing second, she wanted to turn around and tell him everything: that she hadn't slept, that she'd been frightened, that the truth about why she left was uglier and smaller than the version she'd lived with for years.

She drove on.

At the stoplight, her phone lit up with an unfamiliar number. No name, no message—just a call that rang twice and went silent before she could answer.

She waited for a voicemail. None came.

Then a text arrived from the same number.

You should have stayed away from the water.

Avery read it once. Again. The light changed green behind her and someone honked. She drove into the next parking lot and pulled to the far edge, her hands tight on the wheel.

The sender had not simply guessed where she'd been. The message had reached her less than five minutes after she left the marina.

She took a screenshot and called Sheriff Mercer.

While the phone rang, she looked up at the storefront windows across the road, at the vehicles moving past, at a man standing beside a vending machine with a phone in his hand. She could not tell whether anybody was watching her.

This time, she knew somebody had been.

Chapter 3

The Price of Silence

Sheriff Mercer answered on the fourth ring, just as Avery began to wonder whether she was supposed to leave a message saying someone had apparently followed her from the waterfront.

“Bennett?”

Avery watched a delivery driver wrestle a stack of cardboard boxes through the door of the pharmacy across the street. “I got another message.”

Mercer did not ask which message. “Where are you?”

“Parking lot behind Bell's Hardware. Two blocks from the rescue station. I pulled over when it came in.”

“Stay there. Lock your doors.”

“They're locked.”

“Tell me exactly what it says.”

Avery read the words aloud. They sounded less threatening spoken in the bright, ordinary daylight. A truck backed out of a loading bay with its reverse alarm chirping. Someone laughed inside a passing car. The world continued as if a woman could not receive a warning about the water while sitting three hundred yards from it.

“Don't delete it,” Mercer said. “I'll send Deputy Phelps to you. We'll document the number and see what we can get from the carrier. Is anybody with you?”

“No.”

“Do not go looking for whoever sent it.”

“I wasn't planning to.”

“People who are scared sometimes get angry. Angry people do things they weren't planning to.”

Avery looked at the tinted window of a parked pickup. She couldn't see anyone inside. “I've spent eight years avoiding this place. I'm not about to chase a stranger around it.”

A beat of silence passed. “Your father wasn't avoiding it,” Mercer said.

“What does that mean?”

“It means he was asking questions, and now somebody is contacting you. I don't know whether those facts connect. I'm going to find out what I can.”

For once, it was an answer Avery could use.

Phelps arrived in a marked cruiser twelve minutes later. He was younger than she remembered deputies being, broad-shouldered and sunburned, with the apologetic expression of someone accustomed to being called after the worst part was over. He photographed her phone screen, recorded the unfamiliar number, and asked her to describe the man Noah had seen at the station. Avery repeated Noah's description carefully, distinguishing what Noah had actually seen from what she had inferred.

“You know anybody who might want to scare you off a piece of property?” Phelps asked.

“No. I haven't even decided what to do with the place.”

“Folks make assumptions.”

“About property?”

“About just about everything.” He handed the phone back. “Sheriff wants you to call if anything else happens. And she still recommends you spend the night somewhere with company.”

Avery nodded without promising.

When he left, she remained in the driver's seat and opened the email she had been avoiding since before the funeral. It was from a local attorney named Miriam Price, whose office had handled her father's estate. The subject line read: INITIAL ESTATE DOCUMENTS / BENNETT PROPERTY. Avery had already received the appointment information and the probate petition; now there were attachments she would have to review, signatures she would have to provide, and a house full of things she could not bear to sort.

A second email had arrived that morning.

Richard Vale requests a brief meeting at your convenience regarding 16 Marsh Point Road. Mr. Vale understands this is a difficult week and wishes to discuss a straightforward offer that may simplify the estate process.

Her father had once called Vale a man who could put a price tag on fog if the county gave him a permit. The memory came so clearly that Avery almost heard Thomas's gravelly voice beside her.

She clicked the attorney's number before she could think better of it.

Miriam Price spoke like a woman with a dozen other obligations waiting just outside the conversation. She confirmed that the waterfront house was part of the estate and that Avery, as the nominated personal representative and principal beneficiary, would have decisions to make after the court completed the necessary steps. Ethan's status and the terms of the will required review before anyone could promise a sale or distribution.

“Mr. Vale's office has contacted mine twice,” Miriam said. “I told them any purchase discussion was premature.”

“Has he been trying to buy it for long?”

“I can't speak to conversations your father had while he was alive. I can tell you the offer presented this week is substantially above the appraisal estimate.”

“How substantially?”

Miriam gave her a number.

Avery stared at the rain-streaked windshield. There were houses in Charlotte that cost less. “That can't be right.”

“It's the figure on the letter.”

“Why?”

“That's a question for the buyer. My advice is not to commit to anything until we've reviewed the land-use restrictions, the estate obligations, and your father's papers. A large offer can still be a bad one.”

Avery thanked her and ended the call. The offer was a little more than double the property's last assessed value. The house had a rotting porch, a temperamental water heater, and a view that might someday make somebody rich. She could understand a developer wanting the land. She could…

Preview complete

Keep reading Before the Storm Finds Us

You've reached the end of the free preview. Purchase this eBook for permanent access in your Novel Thunder Library, or read it with an eligible Novel Thunder subscription.

Buy eBook — $4.99
Make Novel Thunder smarter for you?

Allow Novel Thunder to remember what you browse on Novel Thunder so we can personalize book recommendations and offers. No cross-site tracking, fingerprinting, or IP-based profile.