The Perfect Mother’s Secretby Mara Smith
×
Free PreviewRead the first 10% — no account required.
The Perfect Mother’s Secret cover
Preview

Chapter 1

The Other Daughter

The notice arrived between a property-tax bill and a coupon for furnace filters.

Natalie Rusk almost threw it away.

The envelope was white, its address visible through a narrow plastic window. Across the upper left corner was the blue seal of Westbridge Public Schools, a district ninety miles from her house in Port Alder. She had never lived in Westbridge. She knew nobody who did.

She placed it beside the kettle and returned to the freezer, where her son had been searching for breakfast for nearly three minutes.

“Nate, what are you doing?”

“Looking.”

“For what?”

“Something.”

“That’s a broad category.”

“Something I can eat.”

“You have cereal.”

“That’s not food.”

She turned. Her thirteen-year-old son had his head inside the freezer, one hand gripping the door while the other pushed aside a bag of frozen vegetables. Cold air spilled across the kitchen tiles.

“You’re letting all the cold out.”

“I’m almost done.”

“You said that a minute ago.”

“Then I was wrong.”

He emerged holding a frozen waffle between two fingers. Natalie looked at it.

“You’re going to toast that?”

“That’s generally how waffles work.”

“One waffle?”

“There’s another one in there. It looks suspicious.”

“Suspicious how?”

“It’s got stuff on it.”

“That’s frost.”

“Could be.”

He closed the freezer and studied the waffle as though deciding whether it had survived an unknown catastrophe. Natalie nearly smiled.

Outside, rain scratched against the kitchen window. The first November cold front had arrived early, turning the trees along Grenadier Street a brittle yellow. The lawn was scattered with wet leaves she had promised herself she would rake before the weekend. Water collected in the shallow depression beside the driveway, where the concrete had settled after the previous winter.

The house had begun showing its age in small, manageable ways. A loose stair tread. A kitchen drawer that stuck in damp weather. The refrigerator seal that no longer held quite as tightly as it should. Natalie maintained a list of repairs on the refrigerator. She crossed things off when they were finished. The list had become longer since the divorce.

“Do we have syrup?” Nate asked.

“Behind the flour.”

“Why?”

“Because that’s where you put it.”

“I don’t remember doing that.”

“You were making pancakes Tuesday.”

“That doesn’t prove anything.”

He opened the cupboard. Natalie picked up the envelope. She assumed it was a professional solicitation. As a speech-language pathologist, she received correspondence from school districts that bought mailing lists without checking whether the recipients worked in their classrooms. Conferences, certification programs, specialized assessment workshops. Occasionally an advertisement for software that promised to replace half her paperwork.

She opened the envelope with her thumb. One folded page. A district letterhead. A subject line in bold: NOTICE OF ATTENDANCE REVIEW.

She skimmed the first paragraph. Then returned to the beginning.

The student was named Maya Rusk. Eight years old. Date of birth: June 22, 2018. The school requested a parent conference concerning twelve unexcused absences and an unresolved transportation arrangement.

Natalie scanned the address. Grenadier Street. Her house. Then she read the line beneath the student’s information: Parent/Legal Guardian: Natalie E. Rusk.

She stopped.

“Nate.”

He had located the syrup and was trying to loosen its cap.

“What?”

“Did you use my name on something?”

He looked up. “Like what?”

“A form. An online application. Anything connected to a school called Westbridge.”

“What’s Westbridge?”

“That’s what I’m asking.”

He studied her for a moment. “Are you doing that thing where you ask questions you already know the answer to?”

“No.”

“Because it sounds like that thing.”

She lowered the letter. “Nate, I’m serious.”

“So am I.”

He put the syrup down. “Did something happen?”

The question came without his usual defensive humor. Natalie disliked how quickly he noticed changes in her voice. Her professional training made her sensitive to the subtle distinctions between a question asked for information and one asked for reassurance. Nate had learned those distinctions at home. He recognized when she was frightened before she admitted it herself.

“Probably a mistake,” she said.

“What kind?”

“Someone sent us another family’s school notice.”

“Then why are you asking whether I did something?”

She had no answer that would satisfy both of them.

“Eat your breakfast.”

“Mom.”

“Please.”

He looked at the page in her hand. “Can I see it?”

“Not yet.”

Something withdrew from his expression. Not anger exactly. An adjustment. He picked up his waffle and left the kitchen. Natalie listened to his footsteps on the stairs.

She had been careful about involving him in adult problems since the divorce. Careful, at least, in the ways she understood. She didn’t complain about child support. She didn’t ask him what Jack said about her. When an argument needed to happen, she tried to keep it out of the rooms Nate occupied.

But children heard more than adults intended. They heard pauses. Changes in volume. A parent saying fine with a mouth shaped for another word.

Natalie taught children to hear differences between consonants, to recognize the sounds that distinguished one meaning from another. Her son had become very good at hearing the things she didn’t say.

She laid the notice flat on the counter. The paper was heavier than standard printer stock. A faint blue line bordered the district seal. The attendance officer’s printed name appeared beneath a space for a handwritten signature. There was no signature. That did not make the letter fraudulent. Many schools generated attendance notices automatically.

She knew the process. She had written recommendations for children whose therapy sessions conflicted with attendance requirements. She had attended meetings where teachers, counselors, and administrators discussed how an absence could be coded incorrectly and then carried forward through a student information system.

Mistakes happened. A transposed number. An incorrect guardian selected from a dropdown menu. An old address left in a file after a family moved.

Those were ordinary errors. This one included her full legal name. Natalie E. Rusk. She had stopped using her middle initial years ago. Her professional license, however, still carried it. So did her mortgage. And the divorce decree.

She read the child’s name again. Maya Rusk. Rusk was not an especially common surname in northern Michigan. But it wasn’t impossible that another family shared it.

She looked at the date of birth. June 22, 2018. A tight sensation formed beneath her ribs. She counted backward automatically. Eight years. She had been thirty-four. Nate had been five. She had been married. Barely.

She placed the notice beneath the kitchen light. A line near the bottom gave a number for Westbridge’s family services office. She called.

A recorded voice answered after three rings. The woman’s articulation was clear but unnaturally even, with every sentence ending in the same downward cadence. An automated system. Natalie recognized the synthetic pauses between clauses.

“Thank you for calling Westbridge Public Schools. Our administrative offices are currently closed.”

She checked the day. Saturday. Of course.

“For attendance matters, please remain on the line.”

She waited. The recorded voice described chronic absenteeism policies, possible intervention procedures, and the importance of regular school attendance.

“To speak with an attendance representative, press zero.”

She pressed zero. The system returned her to the opening message. She tried again. Same result. Natalie ended the call.

On Monday morning, the district expected her to attend a conference concerning a child she had never met. The absurdity might have been funny if the letter had not contained so many accurate details.

She opened her laptop. The kitchen was still warm from the toaster, and the air carried the faint sweet smell of Nate’s breakfast. Outside, a truck drove through the shallow water at the curb. Tires hissed against the road.

Natalie searched the district’s website. Westbridge Public Schools existed. The attendance officer existed. The school listed in the notice existed. She compared the telephone number printed on the letter with the one displayed on the district website. They matched. She checked the postal address. Another match.

The letter might still have been sent in error. But someone had entered her information into a system capable of generating official correspondence.

She typed the child’s full name into a search engine. The first result concerned a youth gymnastics competition in another state. The second was an obituary for a woman named Maya Rusk who had died decades earlier. She closed both pages. An eight-year-old child’s absence from public search results was neither unusual nor evidence of concealment.

She had spent her career warning parents against making diagnostic conclusions from isolated observations. One speech error did not establish a disorder. One missed developmental milestone did not define a child. And one official letter did not prove that somebody had stolen her identity.

She repeated that last sentence silently. It did not make the letter less frightening.

At eleven thirty, she opened the drawer containing Nate’s school documents. The folder was labeled with his name and the current academic year. Inside were vaccination records, emergency contacts, consent forms, and a copy of his most recent learning plan.

Nate had needed speech therapy briefly when he was younger. He’d had difficulty distinguishing certain consonant clusters and occasionally became frustrated when unfamiliar adults asked him to repeat himself. Natalie had not been his treating clinician. She’d insisted on that boundary despite Jack’s objections about paying someone else to do work she understood.

Her son needed a mother who could listen without evaluating. She hadn’t always succeeded.

Now she moved his records aside and retrieved her old travel folder. Cincinnati. Summer 2018. The folder held receipts from an eight-week temporary assignment she had taken while covering for a specialist on medical leave.

She remembered the heat. The broken air conditioner in the rented apartment. The smell of hot asphalt rising from the parking lot after rain. She remembered sleeping beside an open refrigerator one night because the bedroom had become unbearable.

She also remembered how relieved she had been to be away from Jack. The separation had not begun formally until later that year. But the marriage had already developed separate schedules, separate expenses, and separate ways of explaining the distance between them.

She had called the Cincinnati assignment a professional opportunity. Jack had called it an unnecessary disruption. Neither had said that they were relieved to be apart.

Natalie opened her archived photographs. June 23, 2018. There she stood beneath an orange paper lantern at a colleague’s backyard barbecue. A plastic cup in one hand. A plate balanced awkwardly against her hip. Her hair was shorter, the ends brushing her jaw. She wore a sleeveless navy blouse and white trousers.

She was not pregnant. She had not delivered a child the previous day. She knew that without photographs, payroll records, or travel receipts. Yet the official notice had forced her into the ridiculous position of collecting evidence against an accusation nobody had made aloud.

She enlarged the photograph. An orange lantern hung directly above her head. Behind her stood two colleagues whose names she remembered, though she hadn’t spoken to either in years. She could contact them. Request confirmation. Ask whether they remembered the barbecue.

Her mind moved through possible documentation with the practiced efficiency she used when preparing clinical assessments. Then she stopped.

Why was she building an alibi? No one had accused her of anything. The school had asked for a conference. It was possible that the wrong parent had been selected in a database. Possible that another Natalie Rusk existed. Possible that a clerical mistake had passed through several offices without correction.

She wrote those possibilities on a legal pad. Then, beneath them, a question: Who supplied my information?

The words changed the nature of the problem. Until that moment, she had been trying to establish that the notice was wrong. Now she wanted to know how it had become wrong.

Jack arrived six minutes early. Natalie knew the time because she glanced at the oven clock when his dark sedan turned into the driveway.

He parked too close to the retaining wall, as usual. She had asked him not to do it dozens of times. The wall shifted slightly each winter, and there was barely enough clearance to open the passenger door. Jack said she worried about things that might never happen. Natalie said he preferred not to notice problems until someone else had to repair them.

It was the sort of argument that had outlived their marriage.

She slid the notice into the drawer. The movement was automatic. She regretted it before the drawer closed.

Jack let himself in with his own key. She had asked for that back twice. He maintained that both parents should have emergency access to the house while Nate lived there. Natalie had changed the back-door lock after the divorce. She had not changed the front.

“Morning,” Jack said.

He wore jeans, a dark jacket, and the gray running shoes he bought every spring whether the previous pair needed replacing or not.

“He’s ready?”

“Almost.”

Jack glanced toward the kitchen. “You look tired.”

“Thank you.”

“That’s not what I meant.”

“I know.”

He unzipped his jacket. “Something going on?”

She could have told him the school made a mistake. She could have waited until Monday. Instead she said, “Someone sent me an attendance notice for a child I don’t know.”

Jack’s hand stopped on the zipper.

“What child?”

“A girl named Maya Rusk.”

He waited. Natalie watched him closely. There was no visible panic. No sudden movement. But she had lived with him long enough to recognize when he was choosing an answer rather than discovering one.

“School says I’m her mother,” she added.

“Sounds like spam.”

“On district stationery?”

“People fake official documents all the time.”

“The phone number is real.”

“Then it’s probably an administrative error.”

He said it quickly. Too quickly? Natalie examined the thought. Speed was not proof of knowledge. Jack had always answered uncomfortable questions with a practical explanation. Sometimes he was right. Sometimes he simply wanted the conversation to end.

“They have my full name,” she said.

“Public records have your name.”

“My middle initial.”

“That too.”

“And this address.”

He shrugged. “You’re on the property records.”

All technically true. His response irritated her precisely because she couldn’t dispute it.

“Doesn’t it seem strange?”

“Sure.”

“That’s all?”

“What do you want me to say, Natalie?”

“I want you to think about it.”

“I am thinking about it.”

“No. You’re explaining it away.”

Jack looked toward the stairs. “Nate!”

“Coming!”

He lowered his voice. “Look, if somebody sent you the wrong school letter, call the school Monday. They’ll fix it.”

“You don’t know that.”

“Neither do you.”

She looked at him. For a moment they were back inside the marriage, occupying their familiar positions. Natalie asking for something he considered unnecessary. Jack trying to make a problem disappear by defining it as simple.

He had never liked her habit of examining conversations afterward. He once accused her of treating their disagreements like clinical recordings. She had answered that she only wanted them to be precise. He said marriages weren’t depositions. She remembered how much that had hurt.

Now, after nearly three years apart, she wondered whether precision had sometimes become a weapon.

“Nate says he can’t find his headphones,” Jack said.

“He had them yesterday.”

“I’ll help him look.”

He started upstairs. Natalie nearly stopped him. Instead she watched him disappear. From above came the sound of drawers opening. Nate complained that someone had moved his backpack. Jack said the backpack had been in the same place for two weeks. Nate laughed.

Their easy rhythm traveled through the ceiling. Natalie stood alone in the kitchen, remembering how often she had wished Jack would take small problems seriously when they lived together. Now he was upstairs solving one. And she was hiding a letter about a child.

The photograph from Cincinnati remained on her laptop. She closed it. Then opened the drawer again. The notice rested beneath a folder of insurance forms. She took it out and examined the lower portion, where the district had printed a series of contact references.

The first was a student identification number. The second was a parent-contact record. The final line contained a partially masked telephone number: Contact on file: (***) ***-0419.

Natalie stared. She read the digits twice. 0419. Four numbers were hardly a fingerprint. Thousands of telephone numbers ended with the same sequence. Yet the combination felt familiar.

She carried the paper to the dining table and sat. Years earlier, her mother had kept an index card beside the telephone in her kitchen. The card contained emergency numbers, the doctor’s office, the pharmacy, and a prepaid mobile number Natalie recognized immediately because her younger sister had used it.

Leah. The number ended in 0419. Natalie had called it dozens of times. Sometimes Leah answered. Sometimes the line went directly to voicemail. Then, after their final argument, it stopped accepting calls altogether.

She remembered the argument with uncomfortable clarity. Not every word. The exact words had blurred. But she remembered their positions. Leah by the kitchen doorway. Natalie at the table. Their mother standing beside the refrigerator, clutching a dish towel.

Leah had asked for money. Natalie had asked what happened to the money she gave her the previous month. Leah said she needed help, not an audit. Natalie said she couldn’t keep rescuing her from consequences. Leah laughed. It was a terrible little sound.

“You don’t rescue people,” she’d said. “You decide what they should do, then call it helping.”

Natalie had been furious. Because she had given Leah money. Found her apartments. Driven across the state to collect her after a boyfriend locked her out. She had spent years trying to keep her sister safe. And Leah had made it sound like an act of control.

Their mother asked both women to stop. Neither listened. By the end, Leah was crying. Natalie was not. She sometimes wondered whether that was the detail her sister remembered most.

The last thing Leah said before leaving was, “I hope nobody ever needs you in a way you don’t understand.”

The sentence had survived nearly seven years. Now Natalie looked at the telephone suffix again. 0419. She photographed the line. Then she reached for her phone.

Their mother’s number was saved under Mom, despite the fact that Natalie had considered changing it to Ruth after the last difficult holiday. She did not call. Not yet. She wanted to ask Jack something first.

Nate came downstairs with his backpack over one shoulder. Jack followed, holding a pair of tangled headphones.

“Found them,” Nate announced.

“Where?”

“Bathroom.”

Natalie stared. “Why were your headphones in the bathroom?”

“I was listening to something.”

“While showering?”

“Before showering.”

Jack raised one hand. “Don’t ask questions you don’t want answered.”

Nate grinned. Natalie tried to return the smile. Her son noticed.

“Are you okay?”

“Yes.”

“You look weird.”

“Thank you.”

“I mean weirder than usual.”

“Nate.”

“Fine.”

He moved toward the door. Natalie turned to Jack.

“Did Leah ever contact you?”

Jack stopped. Not fully. Only enough that the backpack in his hand brushed the wall.

“Why would she?”

“That’s not what I asked.”

He looked at her. “Not in years.”

“How many years?”

“I don’t keep track.”

“Since she left?”

“Probably.”

Nate stood just behind him. “Who’s Leah?”

Natalie’s stomach tightened. “My sister.”

“The one Grandma doesn’t talk about?”

Jack shifted his weight. Natalie looked at Nate.

“Yes.”

“Is she dead?”

“No.”

“Then why doesn’t anybody talk about her?”

A reasonable question. Natalie had spent years avoiding it. She heard herself preparing a familiar answer about family disagreements and adult complications. The phrasing felt dishonest before she spoke.

“We had a serious argument,” she said. Nate waited. “And we haven’t spoken since.”

“About what?”

“Things I don’t think I understood very well at the time.”

He considered that. “Could you call her?”

“I don’t know where she is.”

“Grandma might.”

Natalie glanced at Jack. His expression remained unreadable.

“Maybe,” she said.

Jack opened the door. “We should get going.”

Nate…

“Sunda…

Preview complete

Keep reading The Perfect Mother’s Secret

You've reached the end of the free preview. Purchase this eBook for permanent access in your Novel Thunder Library, or read it with an eligible Novel Thunder subscription.

Buy eBook — $2.99