Chapter 1: The Gold Sticker
The trouble began with a gold sticker shaped like a trophy.
It was stuck to the top of a sheet of poster board on the science-room door. Underneath, in Ms. Bell's neat handwriting, were the words WILDLIFE CLUB: GREAT WILDLIFE CHALLENGE.
Mara Ortiz stopped so suddenly that the fourth graders behind her nearly walked into her backpack.
"A challenge," she read. "With a trophy."
"It isn't an actual trophy," said her friend Ellis Cho, who could find a mistake in a headline before he finished reading it. "It's a sticker."
"It's a promise," Mara said.
She had joined wildlife club because she loved animals. She had also joined because her older brother, Nico, was good at practically everything: basketball, spelling, remembering which key fit the shed. Mara wanted one thing in their house that belonged to her.
At the door, Ms. Bell handed out permission slips. "The Bracken Creek Nature Center has asked our club to design a small exhibit for its fall open house. Visitors will learn how different animals use the same wetland."
"Which animal wins?" asked Jalen Price.
Ms. Bell held up one finger. "That is not the assignment."
"But the title says challenge," Mara said.
"The challenge is for you to make a useful exhibit. You must compare species fairly."
Aster Reed, who drew animals in the margins of her math workbook, stepped closer. "Could we make giant cardboard animals?"
"Maybe," Ms. Bell said. "After you find out what you'd be showing. Our partner, field naturalist Ms. Sima Patel, will visit on Friday."
Mara looked at the blank wall above the coat hooks. Her mind filled it with a glowing display, a spinning wheel, and a giant blue ribbon. If the exhibit was best, maybe the nature center would put their class picture on its website. Maybe Nico would see it before dinner and say, You really did that?
"We should pick the strongest animal first," Jalen announced. "Then build around it."
"Strongest at what?" Ellis asked.
"At being an animal."
Aster laughed. Mara didn't. She had already opened her notebook to a fresh page and written BEST WETLAND ANIMAL at the top.
By the time the club sat in a circle, four creatures were on the board: painted turtle, muskrat, red-winged blackbird, and dragonfly. Ms. Bell said they were possibilities, not confirmed species at Bracken Creek. Observation and local records would have to come first.
"Turtle," Mara said. "A shell is like carrying your own fortress."
"Dragonfly," Jalen said. "Flying beats crawling."
"Blackbird," Aster said. "They can sit where we can't even reach."
Ellis tapped his pencil on the desk. "A muskrat can use the water and the land. But none of those descriptions tells us whether an animal is better."
"You are taking the fun out of it," Jalen told him.
"I'm asking what the question means."
Ms. Bell moved the stickered poster into the center of their circle. "Here is what the nature center actually asked: How do several local species meet their needs in one wetland? Habitat, food, and safety are good starting points. You will collect observations, compare evidence, and explain what the evidence can and cannot show."
Mara wrote the words under her title, but smaller. She drew a trophy beside turtle anyway.
At home, Nico was constructing a model bridge for a school engineering contest. It stretched across the kitchen table, supported by narrow wooden sticks.
"We got picked to build a nature-center exhibit," Mara told him.
"Cool," Nico said, studying a crooked support. "What's it about?"
"Which wetland animal is the greatest."
"How do you measure that?"
Mara pulled out a chair. "Why does everyone keep asking me that?"
Nico held his bridge in both hands. "Because if somebody said this bridge was the greatest, I'd want to know if they meant longest, strongest, or cheapest."
"I mean the greatest," Mara said.
The bridge tilted. Nico caught it before it fell.
Mara watched a drop of glue run down a stick. Tomorrow, she decided, she would bring enough facts to make the others stop asking questions.
On the way to class, Mara kept hearing the word challenge as though it were a drumbeat. In the hallway, the fifth graders had taped up photographs from their invention fair. One showed a windmill made from spoons. Another showed a tiny vehicle built from bottle caps. Under each picture was a short caption explaining what had worked and what had failed.
Mara studied the photographs longer than she intended. The inventions were impressive, but it was the photographs of their makers that caught her eye. Every child looked as though the project belonged to them. She imagined the wildlife club standing in the same hallway, her turtle crowned in gold at the center.
"You're blocking the drinking fountain," someone said.
Mara stepped aside. Her friend Aster was waiting with a rolled sheet of drawing paper under her arm.
"Can you draw a turtle that looks brave?" Mara asked.
"A turtle can look like a turtle," Aster said. "I'm not giving it eyebrows."
"How about standing on a rock?"
"Turtles don't stand like people on rocks."
"Fine. A very brave-looking log."
Aster laughed. They went into the science room, where the first meeting still buzzed in Mara's head. Jalen was stacking pencils into a tower. Ellis had already drawn lines across a page to organize information. The more Mara watched the others, the more she feared that if she didn't announce a big idea immediately, the project would become somebody else's.
At the end of the meeting, Ms. Bell asked each student to write one reason the exhibit mattered. She gave them small slips of paper, not enough room for a speech.
Aster wrote: People should notice what lives near us.
Ellis wrote: Visitors deserve information they can trust.
Jalen wrote: I want kids to have fun learning, not just read a wall.
Mara stared at her blank slip. She wanted to write: I want to do something amazing. Instead she wrote: I want someone to come into the center and remember our exhibit afterward.
Ms. Bell gathered the slips without comment. Mara was relieved. Her reason felt more private than a science answer.
That evening, after Nico had set his bridge aside, Mara spread the wildlife-club assignment across their kitchen table. Her mother was sorting grocery receipts and preparing tomorrow's lunches. Nico's project had taken one side of the table all week. Mara arranged her paper carefully on the other side so her mother would notice.
"That's a lot of animals," her mother said.
"Only four. And we have to make the best display in the whole center."
"The center is trusting you with a display," her mother answered. "That's a responsibility."
Mara had hoped for a different word. She had hoped for impressive.
"Were you ever in a club that made something important?" she asked.
"When I was in school, our class tried to persuade the town to keep a crosswalk by the library. We measured how many people used it."
"Did you win?"
"They kept the crosswalk. But the traffic engineer changed our first plan. We wanted a flashing light, and the town couldn't put one where we suggested."
"So you lost part of it."
"We got a safer crossing. That was the point."
Mara considered this, then changed the subject. "Could you buy me metallic gold paper?"
Her mother smiled without looking up from the receipts. "We have brown packing paper and a blue marker. Start with those."
Mara made a face at the ordinary supplies. Later, in her room, she built a model of the exhibit using a shoebox. The turtle occupied most of the space. The other animals stood along the edges, squeezed into strips. She moved the turtle to make room, then moved it back because the display looked less spectacular without a large center figure.
At the bottom of the shoebox she wrote the opening sentence of her future presentation: Welcome to the contest to find the greatest animal.
She rehearsed saying it twice, first in a serious voice and then in a voice she imagined a museum guide would use. Neither sounded quite right. She wished there were a way to find out which sentence would impress people before she had to say it in front of them.
For now, the crowned turtle would be enough. She propped the model against her dresser and went to bed convinced the next club meeting would make everything clear.
She spent the evening drawing a turtle with a crown. Beneath it she printed a sentence she had not checked: THE PAINTED TURTLE IS THE TOUGHEST ANIMAL IN BRACKEN CREEK.
The words filled the page beautifully. That was their best feature.
Chapter 2: The Wrong Kind of Facts
On Thursday morning Mara reached the science room before the first bell. Her turtle poster was rolled inside an empty cereal box to keep it flat.
Jalen had brought a chart of animal speeds copied from three websites. He had used a red marker for the biggest numbers and a black one for everything else.
"My chart proves the dragonfly's the champion," he said.
Ellis leaned over. "It says one dragonfly species can fly at a certain speed. Is it the kind we might see at Bracken Creek? And are these speeds measured the same way?"
"They're numbers," Jalen said.
"Numbers have to be about the same thing if you compare them."
Aster unfolded a painting of a blackbird above the reeds. The bird's red shoulder patches looked like two bright sparks. "I haven't written the facts yet. I wanted to see it first."
"At least you admit that," Ellis muttered.
Mara slid her poster onto a table, lifted the cereal box, and let the crowned turtle unroll. Jalen made an impressed sound. Aster smiled.
Then Ellis read the sentence at the bottom.
"How did you measure toughness?"
"It has a shell."
"Did you check whether all animals use defenses the same way?"
"No animal has a better shell."
"A dragonfly doesn't need to be a turtle," Ellis said. "That isn't the same thing."
Mara opened her mouth, but Ms. Bell arrived carrying a crate of clipboards. "I see we have enthusiasm. Now we're going to make room for evidence."
Each clipboard held a field sheet with four columns: time, location, what I saw or heard, and questions. Across the bottom were three boxes labeled DIRECT OBSERVATION, VERIFIED RESEARCH, and INFERENCE.
"An inference is an explanation based on evidence," Ms. Bell said. "It is not the same as a direct observation. If you hear a bird call, you can record the call. You cannot automatically claim the bird is warning its babies."
Jalen raised a hand. "What if you know birds warn babies?"
"You can research a species' behavior. But you still mustn't claim that is why this particular bird called unless your evidence supports it."
Ellis looked pleased enough to float.
They practiced at the classroom windows. A pigeon landed on the railing. Jalen wrote: PIGEON LOOKS FOR LUNCH.
"What did you actually see?" Ms. Bell asked.
"It looked around."
He erased the words and wrote: PIGEON TURNS HEAD LEFT AND RIGHT THREE TIMES.
Mara saw the difference. It felt small, almost annoyingly small. She also noticed that the new sentence was something another person could check.
During recess, she followed Ellis across the blacktop. "You could've said my poster looked good before you questioned it."
"I did think it looked good."
"You didn't say that."
Ellis bent to pick up a dropped jump rope and hooked it over the equipment bin. "You wrote a sentence nobody can prove. If we're going to show it at the nature center, somebody will believe it."
Mara kicked at a pebble. "It was supposed to get people excited."
"People can get excited about something that's true."
She wanted to argue, but a first grader came…
Keep reading The Great Wildlife Challenge
You've reached the end of the free preview. Purchase this eBook for permanent access in your Novel Thunder Library, or read it with an eligible Novel Thunder subscription.
Buy eBook — $4.99